Fitting Foam Simulation Model Parameters for SAG Foam Applications
Authors:
- 2 July 2013
- conference paper
- Published by Society of Petroleum Engineers (SPE)
Abstract
Foam improves sweep in miscible and immiscible gas-injection EOR processes. "SAG" foam processes (injecting alternating slugs of surfactant solution and gas) offer many advantages over co-injection of foam for both operational and sweep-efficiency reasons. The success of a foam SAG process depends on foam behavior at very low injected water fraction (high foam quality), which means that fitting data to a typical scan of foam behavior as a function of foam quality can miss conditions that determine the success of a SAG process. The result can be inaccurate scale-up of results to field application. A successful SAG foam process depends on behavior at very low fractional flow during gas injection and on behavior at larger water fractional flow further from the well where gas and surfactant slugs mix. We illustrate how to fit foam-model parameters to steady-state foam data for application to SAG foam processes. Dynamic SAG corefloods can be unreliable because of failure to reach local steady state (because of slow foam generation), the increased effect of dispersion at the core scale, and the capillary end effect. For current foam models the behavior of foam in SAG depends on the mobility of full-strength foam, the capillary pressure or water saturation at which foam collapses and the parameter governing the abruptness of this collapse. We illustrate how to fit these model parameters to coreflood data, and the challenges that can arise in the fitting process, using the published foam data of Persoff et al. (1991) and Ma et al. (2012). For illustration we use the foam model in the widely used STARS simulator. Having accurate water-saturation data is essential to making a reliable fit to the data. Model fits to a given experiment may result in inaccurate extrapolation to mobility at the wellbore and therefore predicted injectivity: for instance, a model fit in which foam does not collapse even at the extremely large capillary pressure at the wellbore. We show how the insights of fractional-flow theory can guide the model-fitting process and give quick estimates of foam propagation rate, mobility and injectivity at the field scale.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Can Formation Relative Permeabilities Rule Out a Foam EOR Process?SPE Journal, 2012
- Fractional-Flow Theory of Foam Displacements With OilSPE Journal, 2010
- Injection Strategies To Overcome Gravity Segregation in Simultaneous Gas and Water Injection Into Homogeneous ReservoirsSPE Journal, 2009
- Dynamic Simulations With an Improved Model for Foam GenerationSPE Journal, 2007
- Optimal Injection Strategies for Foam IORSPE Journal, 2004
- Simulation of Dynamic Foam-Acid Diversion ProcessesSPE Journal, 2002
- Simplified Mechanistic Simulation of Foam Processes in Porous MediaSPE Journal, 1999
- Numerical Simulation of Foam Flow In Porous MediaJournal of Canadian Petroleum Technology, 1990
- Aqueous Foams for Control of Gas Migration and Water Coning in Aquifer Gas StorageEnergy Sources, 1990
- Effects of Capillary Pressure on Coalescence and Phase Mobilities in Foams Flowing Through Porous MediaSPE Reservoir Engineering, 1988