Quick Anomaly Detection by the Newcomb–Benford Law, with Applications to Electoral Processes Data from the USA, Puerto Rico and Venezuela
Authors:
- Luis PericchiLPLuis Pericchi
- David TorresDTDavid Torres
Open Access
- 1 November 2011
- journal article
- Published by Institute of Mathematical Statistics in Statistical Science
- Vol. 26 (4) , 502-516
Abstract
A simple and quick general test to screen for numerical anomalies is presented. It can be applied, for example, to electoral processes, both electronic and manual. It uses vote counts in officially published voting units, which are typically widely available and institutionally backed. The test examines the frequencies of digits on voting counts and rests on the First (NBL1) and Second Digit Newcomb–Benford Law (NBL2), and in a novel generalization of the law under restrictions of the maximum number of voters per unit (RNBL2). We apply the test to the 2004 USA presidential elections, the Puerto Rico (1996, 2000 and 2004) governor elections, the 2004 Venezuelan presidential recall referendum (RRP) and the previous 2000 Venezuelan Presidential election. The NBL2 is compellingly rejected only in the Venezuelan referendum and only for electronic voting units. Our original suggestion on the RRP (Pericchi and Torres, 2004) was criticized by The Carter Center report (2005). Acknowledging this, Mebane (2006) and The Economist (US) (2007) presented voting models and case studies in favor of NBL2. Further evidence is presented here. Moreover, under the RNBL2, Mebane’s voting models are valid under wider conditions. The adequacy of the law is assessed through Bayes Factors (and corrections of p-values) instead of significance testing, since for large sample sizes and fixed α levels the null hypothesis is over rejected. Our tests are extremely simple and can become a standard screening that a fair electoral process should pass.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- How do numbers begin? (The first digit law)European Journal of Physics, 2007
- Explaining the uneven distribution of numbers in nature: the laws of Benford and ZipfPhysica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 2001
- Calibration ofρValues for Testing Precise Null HypothesesThe American Statistician, 2001
- Objective Bayesian Methods for Model Selection: Introduction and Comparison2001
- A Taxpayer Compliance Application of Benford's Law.The Journal of the American Taxation Association, 1996
- A Statistical Derivation of the Significant-Digit LawStatistical Science, 1995
- Base-Invariance Implies Benford's LawProceedings of the American Mathematical Society, 1995
- Base-invariance implies Benford’s lawProceedings of the American Mathematical Society, 1995
- The First Digit ProblemThe American Mathematical Monthly, 1976
- Note on the Frequency of Use of the Different Digits in Natural NumbersAmerican Journal of Mathematics, 1881