From Social Sciences to Urban Praxis: A Critical Synthesis of Historical–Contextual Inquiry and Analysis in Urban Studies
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
Abstract
This concept paper introduces the Contextual Critical Historical Inquiry and Analysis (CCHIA) framework—a critical synthesis tool designed to advance historical contextual inquiry in urban studies. The study aims to develop a structured methodological framework that integrates historical and critical approaches to enhance the analysis of urban phenomena. To develop this framework, we employed a two-fold strategy, conducting a literature search of the social sciences and urban studies using databases including Google Scholar, Web of Science, JSTOR, and Scopus. First, we screened Google Scholar to identify relevant scholars and works published between 1883 and 2024. Second, a content analysis of 58 peer-reviewed articles (2000–2024) was then performed. The concept paper follows a five-stage, 26-step framework integrating four history-focused concepts—interpretive history, historical perspective, historical context, and historical contextualization—alongside three critical approaches: critical discourse analysis, comparative historical analysis, and critical urban theory. By synthesizing these elements, the suggested framework equips researchers to systematically decode the historical and societal forces shaping urban phenomena. CCHIA challenges traditional urban scholarship by leveraging interdisciplinary insights from the social sciences, addressing context as a theoretical perspective for understanding urban formation, and as a critical influence on academic writing. The contribution of CCHIA lies in linking historical analysis to contemporary urban challenges—enabling researchers to focus on previous literature analysis findings to address the current situation’s challenges. The CCHIA framework offers an adaptable toolkit for producing socially engaged and context-sensitive urban textbooks.Keywords
This publication has 94 references indexed in Scilit:
- Stimulating architects’ mental imagery reaching innovation: Lessons from urban history in using analogies and metaphorsAin Shams Engineering Journal, 2024
- The interaction of history and modern thought in the creation of Iran's architecture by investigating the approaches of past-oriented architectureFrontiers of Architectural Research, 2024
- A systematic review of studies at the intersection of urban climate and historical urban landscapeEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2022
- Critical discourse analysis of urban park and public space developmentCities, 2022
- Closing the gap between text and context in academic writing research—An “impossible” task?Journal of English for Academic Purposes, 2018
- The Social Burden of Resilience: A Historical PerspectiveHuman Ecology, 2018
- Historical Research Approaches to the Analysis of InternationalisationManagement International Review, 2016
- Teaching historical contextualization: the construction of a reliable observation instrumentEuropean Journal of Psychology of Education, 2016
- Putting research data into context: Scholarly, professional, and educational approaches to curating data for reuseProceedings of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 2014
- Evaluation of fitness of design in urban historical context: From the perspectives of residentsFrontiers of Architectural Research, 2013