Intermolecular Interactions in Ionic Crystals of Nucleobase Chlorides—Combining Topological Analysis of Electron Densities with Energies of Electrostatic Interactions
Open Access
Abstract
Understanding intermolecular interactions in crystals of molecular ions continues to be difficult. On the one hand, the analysis of interactions from the point of view of formal charges of molecules, similarly as it is commonly done for inorganic ionic crystals, should be performed. On the other hand, when various functional groups are present in the crystal, it becomes natural to look at the interactions from the point of view of hydrogen bonding, π…π stacking and many other kinds of non-covalent atom–atom bonding. Often, these two approaches seem to lead to conflicting conclusions. On the basis of experimental charge densities of cytosinium chloride, adeninium chloride hemihydrate, and guanine dichloride crystals, with the help of theoretical simulations, we have deeply analysed intermolecular interactions among protonated nucleobases, chloride anions and water molecules. Here, in the second paper of the series of the two (Kumar et al., 2018, IUCrJ 5, 449–469), we focus on applying the above two approaches to the large set of dimers identified in analysed crystals. To understand electrostatic interactions, we analysed electrostatic interaction energies (Ees) computed directly from molecular charge densities and contrasted them with energies computed only from net molecular charges, or from a sum of electric multipolar moments, to find the charge penetration contribution to Ees. To characterize non-covalent interactions we performed topological analyses of crystal electron densities and estimated their interaction energies (EEML) from properties of intermolecular bond critical points. We show that the overall crystal architecture of the studied compounds is governed by the tight packing principle and strong electrostatic attractions and repulsions between ions. Many ions are oriented to each other in a way to strengthen attractive electrostatic interactions or weaken strong repulsion, but not all of them. Numerous bond critical points and bond paths were found between ions, including nucleobase cations despite their overall repulsive interactions. It is clear there is no correlation between EEML and Ees. However, strong relation between EEML and the charge penetration component of Ees is observed. The relation holds regardless of interaction types or whether or not interacting molecules bear the same or opposite charges. Thus, a charge density-based approach for computing intermolecular interaction energies and the atom–atom approach to analyse non-covalent interactions do complement each other, even in ionic systems.Keywords
Funding Information
- the National Centre of Science (Poland) (NN204129138)
- the Department of Chemistry, University of Warsaw (120000-501/86-DSM-110200)
- the PL-Grid (ELESAPT2016)
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- Tracing environment effects that influence the stability of anion–anion complexes: The case of phosphate–phosphate interactionsChemical Physics Letters, 2013
- From a Single Molecule to Molecular Crystal Architectures: Structural and Energetic Studies of Selected Uracil DerivativesCrystal Growth & Design, 2012
- Efficient computer modeling of organic materials. The atom–atom, Coulomb–London–Pauli (AA-CLP) model for intermolecular electrostatic-polarization, dispersion and repulsion energiesNew Journal of Chemistry, 2011
- Cation−Cation “Attraction”: When London Dispersion Attraction Wins over Coulomb RepulsionInorganic Chemistry, 2011
- Definition of Molecular Structure: By Choice or by Appeal to Observation?The Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 2010
- Bond Paths Are Not Chemical BondsThe Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 2009
- Towards a realistic model for the quantitative evaluation of intermolecular potentials and for the rationalization of organic crystal structures. Part I. PhilosophyElectronic Supplementary Information (ESI) is available: the GAUSSIAN input files, the Pixel-SCDS input and output files have been deposited. See http://www.rsc.org/suppdata/ce/b3/b311831b/CrystEngComm, 2003
- Inter-anion O–H−···O− hydrogen bond like interactions: the breakdown of the strength–length analogyChemical Communications, 1998
- Crystal field effects on the topological properties of the electron density in molecular crystals: The case of ureaThe Journal of Chemical Physics, 1994
- Electron affinities of the first-row atoms revisited. Systematic basis sets and wave functionsThe Journal of Chemical Physics, 1992