Decarbonizing STIB Bus Fleet: A Multi-Criteria Comparison of Battery Electric and Hydrogen Fuel Cell Buses
Preprint
- 20 August 2026
- preprint
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Abstract
This study evaluates the optimal technological pathway for the Brussels Intercommunal Transport Company (STIB) to progressively decarbonize its urban surface transit fleet. A comprehensive, region-specific evaluation framework is developed, comparing Battery Electric Buses (BEBs) and Fuel Cell Electric Buses (FCEBs) across three key pillars: environmental performance, economic feasibility, and operational practicality. The methodology integrates a cradle-to-grave Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), a discounted Net Present Value Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) model, semi-structured interviews with transit engineering experts, and a final Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) matrix. The LCA results demonstrate that environmental benefits are highly contingent upon upstream energy pathways; under an optimized low-carbon Belgian electricity mix and renewable electrolysis, FCEBs achieve lower lifetime emissions than BEBs (0.21 versus 0.30kgCO2e/km), though this advantage is entirely neutralized if fossil-derived grey hydrogen is used. Conversely, the TCO analysis outlines a severe economic penalty for hydrogen fleets; over a 15-year design lifespan and 675,000 km of operation, BEBs achieve a standardized unit cost of 1.19bad hbox compared to 1.84bad hbox for FCEBs, a gap driven by current green hydrogen market price premiums relative to grid electricity. Empirical interview results confirm that BEBs exhibit superior localized practicality due to established infrastructure compatibility, mature depot electrification roadmaps, and high power supply reliability, which offset the FCEB’s theoretical advantages in range and refueling logistics. Finally, the multi-criteria analysis confirms that BEBs represent the optimal near-to-mid-term transition pathway for STIB, securing a global suitability score of 0.94 compared to 0.76 for FCEBs.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Version 1, 2026-08-20, Preprints
- Published version: World Electric Vehicle Journal, 17 (10), 536.
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- The road to hydrogen mobility: why fuel cell vehicles could surpass battery electric vehicles in European Union’s long-term climate strategyFuel, 2026
- A techno-economic life cycle assessment of H2 fuelled and electrified urban busesApplied Energy, 2025
- Fuel consumption of diesel, natural gas, hybrid, full electric and hydrogen fuel cells based buses: A simulated comparison using standard road cycles and gradeability testsFuel, 2025
- Mitigating urban pollution: A comparative life cycle assessment of hydrogen, electric, and diesel buses for urban transportationInternational Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2025
- Lifecycle CO2 analysis for urban emission reduction of hydrogen-fuelled and battery electric buses in the European Union current and future energetic scenariosInternational Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2025
- Optimal configuration of hydrogen- and battery-based electric bus transit systemsInternational Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2025
- Liquid hydrogen refueling stations as an alternative to gaseous hydrogen refueling stations: Process development and integrative analyseseTransportation, 2024
- State of Health (SoH) estimation methods for second life lithium-ion battery—Review and challengesApplied Energy, 2024
- Fueling tomorrow's commute: Current status and prospects of public bus transit fleets powered by sustainable hydrogenInternational Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2024
- Monitored data and social perceptions analysis of battery electric and hydrogen fuelled buses in urban and suburban areasJournal of Energy Storage, 2023