Ethical dilemmas and their impact on nurses’ moral agency have been extensively discussed in nursing ethics and research, highlighting the ethical complexity of nursing and the resulting demands on nurses’ moral judgements and responses. Since the early bioethics movement in the 1970s, ethical dilemmas between equally demanding principles have provided a fundamental epistemological category within healthcare ethics. In the past, many nursing scholars have challenged the dominance of this ‘dilemma paradigm’ and advocated for counter-epistemologies based on relationships, dependencies, power, and gender. While this historical lens reveals the ambivalent role of ethical dilemmas in shaping contemporary nursing ethics, the moral philosophical lens focuses on their logical possibility and distinguishes ‘true’ and ‘false’ dilemmas. The experiential lens links the everyday experience of ethical dilemmas to psychological responses, such as moral distress, and explores a diagnostic role for moral emotions, such as regret or guilt. By merging these three lenses, this chapter proposes a nuanced understanding of how ethical dilemmas impact nurses’ moral agency and identifies potential misuses of the term. In this chapter, I will outline strategies to enhance or restore nurses’ moral agency when faced with difficult or even ‘impossible’ choices.