Comparative Assessment of YOLO Segmentation Extensions for Intelligent Fire Detection
Authors:
- Sugi ChoiSCSugi Choi
- Heejun KwonHKHeejun Kwon
- Jiwon ChoiJCJiwon Choi
- Sangwon LeeSLSangwon Lee
- Haiyoung JungHJHaiyoung Jung
Open Access
- 30 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by Korea Institute of Fire Science and Engineering in International Journal of Fire Science and Engineering
- Vol. 39 (3) , 26-36
Abstract
With the growing frequency of fire incidents, the demand for rapid and accurate fire detection technologies has become increasingly critical. In this study, we evaluate segmentation-based object detection models YOLO (You Only Look Once) v5-seg, YOLOv8-seg, and YOLOv11-seg for their ability to detect flames and smoke under identical experimental conditions. A total of 5,000 fire images were collected and split into training, validation, and test datasets. The same hardware environment and hyperparameter settings were used for model training to ensure a fair comparison. The experimental results reveal that YOLOv11-seg achieved the best overall performance, with a Precision of 0.710, Recall of 0.570, F1-score of 0.632, and mAP (mean Average Precision) 50 of 0.600. Notably, YOLOv11-seg achieved the highest Recall and mAP values for smoke detection, underscoring its effectiveness in identifying smoke—a critical factor for early fire detection. In terms of efficiency, YOLOv8-seg demonstrated the fastest inference speed, while YOLOv5-seg offered advantages in lightweight model size. However, YOLOv11-seg provided a balanced trade-off between computational cost and detection accuracy, making it the most suitable model for real-world fire response scenarios. Accordingly, this study proposes YOLOv11-seg as a robust baseline model for segmentation-based fire detection and provides a foundational reference for future research on deep learning-driven intelligent fire video analysis.Keywords
Funding Information
- Korea Agency for Infrastructure Technology Advancement
- Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport (202102220002)
- National Research Foundation of Korea (2021R1G1A1014385)
- Ministry of Science and ICT
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Optimized Faster R-CNN with Swintransformer for Robust Multi-Class Wildfire DetectionFire, 2025
- Fire and Smoke Detection Based on Improved YOLOV11IEEE Access, 2025
- Light-YOLOv8-Flame: A Lightweight High-Performance Flame Detection AlgorithmarXiv, 2025
- DSS-YOLO: an improved lightweight real-time fire detection model based on YOLOv8Scientific Reports, 2025
- Evaluating Segmentation-Based Deep Learning Models for Real-Time Electric Vehicle Fire DetectionFire, 2025
- Improved YOLOv5: Efficient Object Detection for Fire ImagesFire, 2025
- Study on Improving Detection Performance of Wildfire and Non-Fire Events Early Using Swin TransformerIEEE Access, 2025
- Fire detection methods based on an optimized YOLOv5 algorithmEmergency Management Science and Technology, 2023