Survey and Comparative Study of LoRa-Enabled Simulators for Internet of Things and Wireless Sensor Networks
Open Access
Abstract
The Internet of Things (IoT) is one of the most important emerging technologies, spanning a myriad of possible applications, especially with the increasing number and variety of connected devices. Several network simulation tools have been developed with widely varying focuses and used in many research fields. Thus, it is critical to simulate the work of such systems and applications before actual deployment. This paper explores the landscape of available IoT and wireless sensor networks (WSNs) simulators and compares their performance using the Low Power Wide Area Network (LPWAN) communication technology called LoRa (Long Range), which has recently gained a lot of interest. Using a systematic approach, we present a chronological survey of available IoT and WSNs simulation tools. With this, we categorized and content-analyzed published scientific papers in the IoT and WSNs simulation tools research domain by highlighting the simulation tools, study type, scope of study and performance measures of the studies. Next, we present an overview of LoRa/LoRaWAN technology by considering its architecture, transmission parameters, device classes and available simulation tools. Furthermore, we discussed three popular open-source simulation tools/frameworks, namely, NS-3, OMNeT++ (FLoRa) and LoRaSim, for the simulation of LoRa/LoRaWAN networks. Finally, we evaluate their performance in terms of Packet Delivery Ratio (PDR), CPU utilization, memory usage, execution time and the number of collisions.Keywords
This publication has 133 references indexed in Scilit:
- Wireless sensor network simulation frameworks: A tutorial review: MATLAB/Simulink bests the restIEEE Consumer Electronics Magazine, 2016
- Comparison of simulators for assessing the ability to sustain wireless sensor networks using dynamic network reconfigurationSustainable Computing: Informatics and Systems, 2016
- A Research Survey on Experimental Tools for Simulating Wireless Sensor NetworksInternational Journal of Computer Applications, 2013
- Choice of efficient simulator tool for wireless sensor networks2013
- Simulators for Wireless Sensor Networks: A ReviewInternational Journal of Computer Applications, 2013
- An Agent-Based Multi-Model Tool for Simulating Multiple Concurrent Applications in WSNsJournal of Advances in Computer Networks, 2013
- Future Internet: The Internet of Things Architecture, Possible Applications and Key Challenges2012
- Calibrating and Comparing Simulators for Wireless Sensor Networks2011
- A Comparative Study of Wireless Sensor Networks and Their Routing ProtocolsSensors, 2010
- Wireless sensor network surveyComputer Networks, 2008