Comparative Analysis of Stress Responses in Medical Students Using Virtual Reality Versus Traditional 3D-Printed Mannequins for Pericardiocentesis Training
Authors:
- Alberto Rubio-LópezAlberto Rubio-López
- Alejandro Rubio NavasANAlejandro Rubio Navas
Preprint
Abstract
Background: As medical education evolves, innovative methods like virtual reality (VR) and 3D-printed mannequins are increasingly used to simulate high-stress medical scenarios realistically. This study investigates the effectiveness of VR and 3D-printed mannequins in replicating stress levels during pericardiocentesis training, comparing their impact on the emotional and physiological responses of learners. Methods: We enrolled 108 final-year medical students who were randomized to train with both VR and 3D-printed mannequins. Heart rate variability (HRV) analysis was employed to assess stress responses. Additionally, a secondary analysis examined the influence of demographic factors, lifestyle, medication use, and academic stress on these responses. Results: Both VR and traditional mannequin-based training methods proved equally effective in simulating the stress levels encountered in real medical procedures. Our findings indicate significant interactions between stress markers and demographic factors, which highlights the complex nature of stress responses in medical education and underscores the necessity for personalized training approaches. Conclusion: The study validates the use of VR as a viable alternative to traditional mannequins, capable of simulating the technical skills and emotional pressures of medical procedures such as pericardiocentesis. Incorporating VR into medical training programs may enhance learning outcomes and accessibility, particularly in settings constrained by resources.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Views on Augmented Reality, Virtual Reality, and 3D Printing in Modern Medicine and Education: A Qualitative Exploration of Expert OpinionJournal of Digital Imaging, 2023
- 3D printing applications for healthcare research and developmentGlobal Health Journal, 2022
- O018 A virtual reality training platform for surgeons, anaesthetists, and obstetricians in low and middle-income countriesBritish Journal of Surgery, 2022
- Using Heart Rate Variability for Comparing the Effectiveness of Virtual vs Real Training Environments for FirefightersIEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 2022
- A comprehensive method to design and assess mixed reality simulationsVirtual Reality, 2022
- Combining virtual reality and 3D‐printed models to simulate patient‐specific dental operative procedures—A study exploring student perceptionsEuropean Journal of Dental Education, 2021
- Contextual bias, the democratization of healthcare, and medical artificial intelligence in low‐ and middle‐income countriesBioethics, 2021
- Lifestyle, psychological, socioeconomic and environmental factors and their impact on hypertension during the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemicJournal Of Hypertension, 2020
- Evaluating Open Source Software for 3D Imaging and Morphing in Cosmetic and Reconstructive SurgeryThe Laryngoscope, 2020
- Virtual Simulation to Increase Self-efficacy Through Deliberate PracticeNurse Educator, 2019