Do norms and identity matter? Community and power in Southeast Asia's regional order
Author:
- Amitav AcharyaAAAmitav Acharya
- 1 March 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Pacific Review
- Vol. 18 (1) , 95-118
Abstract
This article reviews Michael Leifer's contribution to the study of Southeast Asian regionalism, particularly the role of ASEAN and the ASEAN Regional Forum. Unlike some who portray Leifer as a realist or a neo-realist who totally dismissed the role of ASEAN in the regional order, this article argues that the real difference between Leifer's and the newer constructivist understanding of Southeast Asia is not so much over whether regionalism matters, but under what conditions does it matter. Leifer viewed material forces, such as the prior existence of a great-power balance as a precondition of effective regionalism. He paid less attention to norm dynamics and the politics of regional identity formation. He did not consider them as independent forces in regional order. This paper argues that taking a more sociological approach, factoring in the role of regional norms and identity formation offers a more complete explanation of ASEAN's achievements and failures than Leifer's diplomatic investigations focusing on the balance of power. This also opens the space for a more transformative understanding of Asian security order in which socialization and institution-building are to be seen not merely as adjuncts to the balance of power dynamics, but as shapers of the regional balance of power.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- How Ideas Spread: Whose Norms Matter? Norm Localization and Institutional Change in Asian RegionalismInternational Organization, 2004
- Will Asia's Past Be Its Future?International Security, 2004
- The ASEAN peace process: A category mistakeThe Pacific Review, 1999
- Security communities in theoretical perspective1998
- Collective identity and conflict management in Southeast Asia1998
- Ideas, identity, and institution‐building: From the ‘ASEAN way’ to the ‘Asia‐Pacific way'?The Pacific Review, 1997
- The Promise of Institutionalist TheoryInternational Security, 1995
- Some Problems in the Ancient History of the Hinduized States of South-East AsiaJournal of Southeast Asian History, 1964
- The Structure of Southeast Asian History: Some Preliminary ObservationsJournal of Southeast Asian History, 1962
- On the Possibility of an Autonomous History of Modern Southeast AsiaJournal of Southeast Asian History, 1961