Comparison of safety and stability of C-2 pars and pedicle screws for atlantoaxial fusion: meta-analysis and review of the literature
- 1 December 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Journal of Neurosurgery Publishing Group (JNSPG) in Journal of Neurosurgery: Spine
- Vol. 17 (6) , 577-593
Abstract
Object: Some centers report a lower incidence of vertebral artery (VA) injury with C-2 pars screws compared with pedicle screws without sacrificing construct stability, despite biomechanical studies suggesting greater load failures with C-2 pedicle screws. The authors reviewed published series describing C-2 pars and pedicle screw implantation and atlantoaxial fusions and compared the incidence of VA injury, screw malposition, and successful atlantoaxial fusion with each screw type. Methods: Online databases were searched for English-language articles between 1994 and April of 2011 describing the clinical and radiographic outcomes following posterior atlantoaxial fusion with C-1 lateral mass and either C-2 pars interarticularis or pedicle screws. Thirty-three studies describing 2975 C-2 pedicle screws and 11 studies describing 405 C-2 pars screws met inclusion criteria for the safety analysis. Seven studies describing 113 patients treated with C-2 pars screws and 20 studies describing 918 patients treated with C-2 pedicle screws met inclusion criteria for fusion analysis. Standard and formal meta-analysis techniques were used to compare outcomes. Results: All studies provided Class III evidence. Ten instances of VA injury occurred with C-2 pedicle screws (0.3%) and no VA injury occurred with pars screws. The point estimate of VA injury for C-2 pedicle screws was 1.09% (95% CI 0.73%–1.63%) and was similar to that of C-2 pars screws (1.48%, 95% CI 0.62%–3.52%). Similarly, there was no statistically significant difference in the rate of clinically significant screw malpositions (1.14% [95% CI 0.77%–1.69%) vs 1.69% [95% CI 0.73%–3.84%]). Radiographically identified screw malposition occurred in a higher proportion of C-2 pedicle screws compared with C-2 pars screws (6.0% [95% CI 3.7%–9.6%] vs 4.0% [95% CI 2.0%–7.6%], p < 0.0001). Pseudarthrosis occurred in a greater proportion of patients treated with C-2 pars screws (5 [4.4%] of 113) compared with those treated with C-2 pedicle screws (2 [0.22%] of 900). Point estimates with 95% confidence intervals show a slightly higher rate of successful atlantoaxial fusion in the pedicle screw cohort (97.8% [CI 96.0%–98.8%] vs 93.5% [CI 86.6%–97.0%]; p < 0.0001). Q-testing ruled out heterogeneity between the study groups. Conclusions: With a thorough knowledge of axis anatomy, surgeons can place both C-2 pars and C-2 pedicle screws accurately with a small risk of VA injury or clinically significant malposition. There may be subtle trade-off of safety for rigidity when using axial pedicle instead of pars screws, and the decision to use either screw type must be made only after careful review of the preoperative CT imaging and must take into account the surgeon's expertise and the particular demands of the clinical scenario in any given case.Keywords
This publication has 74 references indexed in Scilit:
- Targeting a Safe Entry Point for C2 Pedicle Screw Fixation in Patients with Atlantoaxial InstabilityJournal of Korean Neurosurgical Society, 2011
- C1 Lateral Mass Screw Insertion With Protection of C1-C2 Venous SinusSpine, 2010
- C1 lateral mass screw placement with intentional sacrifice of the C2 ganglion: functional outcomes and morbidity in elderly patientsEuropean Spine Journal, 2010
- Bilateral C1 laminar hooks combined with C2 pedicle screws fixation for treatment of C1–C2 instability not suitable for placement of transarticular screwsEuropean Spine Journal, 2010
- Accuracy and complications of transpedicular C2 screw placement without the use of spinal navigationEuropean Spine Journal, 2010
- Placement and complications of cervical pedicle screws in 144 cervical trauma patients using pedicle axis view techniques by fluoroscopeEuropean Spine Journal, 2009
- Outcomes of C1 and C2 posterior screw fixation for upper cervical spine fusionEuropean Spine Journal, 2009
- Posterior atlanto-axial fixation with polyaxial C1 lateral mass screws and C2 pars screwsActa Neurochirurgica, 2009
- Atlantoaxial fixation using the polyaxial screw–rod systemEuropean Spine Journal, 2006
- Computer-assisted screw insertion for cervical disorders in rheumatoid arthritisEuropean Spine Journal, 2006