Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis: Identification of Factors Influencing Milking Frequency of Cows in Automatic Milking Systems Combined with Grazing
Open Access
Abstract
More dairy farms (up to more than one in four in some countries) are equipped with automatic milking systems (AMS) worldwide. Because of the positive impacts of grazing, e.g., on animal welfare or on production costs, numerous researchers have published papers on the combination of AMS with grazing. However, pasture-based AMS usually causes a reduction in milking frequency (MF) compared to indoors systems. The objectives of this meta-analysis were to review publications on the impacts of pasture-based AMS on MF and mitigation strategies. First, data from 43 selected studies were gathered in a dataset including 14 parameters, and on which a Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was performed, leading to the description of four clusters summarizing different management practices. Multiple pairwise comparisons were performed to determine the relationship between the highlighted parameters of MF on milk yield (MY). From these different analyses, the relationship between MF and MY was confirmed, the systems, i.e., Clusters 1 and 2, that experienced the lowest MF also demonstrated the lowest MY/cow per day. In these clusters, grazed grass was an essential component of the cow’s diet and low feeding costs compensated MY reduction. The management options described in Clusters 3 and 4 allowed maintenance of MF and MY by complementing the cows’ diets with concentrates or partial mixed ration supplied at the AMS feeding bin or provided at barn. The chosen management options were closely linked to the geographical origin of the papers indicating that other factors (e.g., climatic conditions or available grasslands) could be decisional key points for AMS management strategies.Keywords
Funding Information
- FP7 Ideas: European Research Council (314879)
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Differences in Voluntary Cow Traffic between Holstein and Illawarra Breeds of Dairy Cattle in a Pasture-based Automatic Milking SystemAsian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences, 2014
- Grazing Soybean to Increase Voluntary Cow Traffic in a Pasture-based Automatic Milking SystemAsian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences, 2014
- Milking frequency management in pasture-based automatic milking systems: A reviewLivestock Science, 2014
- Factors associated with extended milking intervals in a pasture-based automatic milking systemLivestock Science, 2013
- Effect of pre- versus postmilking supplementation on traffic and performance of cows milked in a pasture-based automatic milking systemJournal of Dairy Science, 2013
- Sustainability evaluation of automatic and conventional milking systems on organic dairy farms in DenmarkNJAS: Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences, 2012
- Supplementary feeding at milking and minimum milking interval effects on cow traffic and milking performance in a pasture-based automatic milking systemJournal of Dairy Research, 2007
- Assessing heterogeneity in meta-analysis: Q statistic or I² index?Psychological Methods, 2006
- Management of grasslands in intensive dairy livestock farmingLivestock Production Science, 2005
- Effect of sward height and distance between pasture and barn on cows’ visits to an automatic milking system and other behaviourLivestock Production Science, 2000