Between Relativism and Imperialism: Navigating Moral Diversity in Cross‐Cultural Bioethics
Author:
- 21 April 2014
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Developing World Bioethics
- Vol. 15 (3) , 162-171
Abstract
The need for explicit theoretical reflection on cross‐cultural bioethics continues to grow as the spread of communication technologies and increased human migration has made interactions between medical professionals and patients from different cultural backgrounds much more common. I claim that this need presents us with the following dilemma. On the one hand, we do not want to operate according to an imperialist ethical framework that denies and silences the legitimacy of cultural values other than our own. On the other hand, we do not want to backslide into a form of cultural relativism that is unable to critically appraise cultural practices that are harmful, unjust, or oppressive. I examine two prominent attempts – the principlism of Tom Beauchamp and James Childress and the Contractarianism of Robert Baker – to frame cross‐cultural bioethics between these two extremes and argue that both approaches have significant flaws. The principlist approach fails to provide a non‐question begging way to identify cross‐cultural norms that does not already assume the universal legitimacy of moral principles dominant in North American society. Baker's contractarianism cannot grapple with the realities of political power imbalances that often characterize cross‐cultural moral disputes. I suggest that a naturalized feminist framework, though not free of its own theoretical difficulties, provides the best alternative for approaching moral diversity respectfully and critically.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Moral Status, Justice, and the Common Morality: Challenges for the Principlist Account of Moral ChangeKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 2013
- Ethics Naturalized: Feminism's Contribution to Moral EpistemologyMetaphilosophy, 2000
- A Defense of Fundamental Principles and Human Rights: A Reply to Robert BakerKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 1998
- Negotiating International Bioethics: A Response to Tom Beauchamp and Ruth MacklinKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 1998
- The Mettle of Moral Fundamentalism: A Reply to Robert BakerKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 1998
- A Theory of International Bioethics: Multiculturalism, Postmodernism, and the Bankruptcy of FundamentalismKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 1998
- A Theory of International Bioethics: The Negotiable and the Non-NegotiableKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 1998
- Justice, Gender, and International Boundaries1993