Abstract
In this chapter, we engage in a trialogue about the role that gender plays in men’s violence against women and, subsequently, in public health and broader social justice efforts to prevent and address it. The conversation that follows reflects our unpacking of gender as a concept and as a social determinant of health: how it is defined and how these definitions impact public health approaches to addressing men’s violence and promoting social justice. Our intention behind this chapter is to encourage a maturation of perspectives on gender and public health, moving on from a phase of simply thinking about the effects of gender on men and women to thinking about what kind of relationship we understand gender as having to power. In doing so, we complicate understandings of gender currently represented in public health and call for a rethinking of the term as a social determinant of health in relation to public health approaches to men’s violence. This chapter is a trialogue because, while we share concerns about the ways in which gender is conceptualised in public health, we each approach the topic from different perspectives, locations and experiences. Given this, we wanted to move away from an authoritative, monological voice to write in an engaged way in response to each other and to provoke further questions and provide space for complexity. What follows is an edited version of a transcript of our recorded, spoken discussion where we grapple with the tensions and contradictions of representations of gender in public health. This trialogue also benefitted from subsequent collaborative discussions and edits. We start by introducing ourselves in the third person before writing in the first person about our motivation for engaging in this conversation. Natalie is a Vice Chancellor’s Senior Research Fellow at the Social Equity Research Centre (SERC) and School of Health and Biomedical Sciences, RMIT University. Her research looks extensively at the role of gender norms, roles and stereotypes in shaping women’s harmful relationships with food and their bodies. Bob is an Honorary Professor at Deakin University and the University of Tasmania. He has published extensively in critical studies of men and masculinities and profeminist approaches to engaging men in violence prevention. He is a founding member of Men against Sexual Assault and continues to be involved in community-based violence prevention campaigns. Meagan is a Senior Lecturer in Research Education and Development at La Trobe University. She has spent the last two decades researching and writing on gender inequality and violence against women in a range of contexts, from the sex industry and sexual exploitation to emergency management and disaster.