A systematic review of sensors to combat crime and routes to further sensor development
Authors:
Open Access
- 12 June 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Chemistry
- Vol. 13, 1568867
Abstract
Forensic science plays an important part in crime reduction but faces many challenges. These include the validity, cost and complexity of current sensors used, and a reliance on trained professionals to conduct analyses. Recent advances in sensor technologies present a promising opportunity for rapid, decentralized, and cost-effective analysis by untrained individuals in the field. To date, a comprehensive systematic review covering sensing technologies and use cases has been lacking. This paper addresses that gap. After the initial screening of papers, 1,482 publications were included in the review, from which data on target analytes and sensing technologies were extracted. Given that law enforcement have limited resources, a second screening examined papers that focused on low-cost sensing devices published from 2020 onwards (N = 791). Overall, our review identified eleven key analyte categories that had been researched: illicit drugs, fingerprints, explosives, body fluids, food safety, poisons and toxins, pollutants, counterfeits and documentation, fire, gunshot, and others. Low-cost sensing technologies identified were categorised into electrochemical, colourimetric, immunoassay, luminescence and SERS. We review trends in the research reported, barriers to commercialisation and adoption, and review the use of these types of sensors by law enforcement agencies. Current sensors used by authorities face challenges of high costs, specificity issues, limited detection capabilities and complex sample preparation. Emerging research focuses on cost-effective printed electrodes and dual detection techniques to enhance analyte sensitivity and detection accuracy. Notably, body fluid analysis plays a crucial role in criminal cases, but current sensors suffer issues like false positives, DNA degradation, and high costs. Studies investigating eco-friendly materials and dual-detection approaches show promise in addressing these issues. Illicit drug analysis constitutes over one-third (36%) of included publications. In the UK, police rely on NIK tests and DrugWipe sensors for on-site drug detection, but challenges related to sensitivity, specificity, and confirmatory testing persist. Ongoing research explores dual detection methods, lateral flow immunoassays, and electro-chemiluminescent screening to enhance specificity and matrix tolerance. Future efforts should prioritise refining dual detection methods, reducing matrix interference, low-cost/eco-friendly materials and fostering collaboration between academia and law enforcement for effective implementation in these areas.Keywords
This publication has 827 references indexed in Scilit:
- State‐of‐the‐art electrochemical sensors for quantitative detection of pesticidesApplied Organometallic Chemistry, 2023
- Rough Surface Enhanced Interfacial Synthesis of Core‐Shell Magnetic Fluorescent Microspheres for Enhanced Latent Fingerprint VisualizationAdvanced Materials Interfaces, 2023
- DNA functionalized plasmonic nanoassemblies as SERS sensors for environmental analysisAggregate, 2022
- Instantaneous High‐Resolution Visual Imaging of Latent Fingerprints in Water Using Color‐Tunable AIE Pincer ComplexesAdvanced Materials, 2022
- Nanomaterial‐Based Sensor Arrays With Deep Learning for Screening of Illicit DrugsAdvanced Materials Technologies, 2022
- A March to Shape Optical Artificial Olfactory System toward Ultrasensitive Detection of Improvised ExplosivesAdvanced Photonics Research, 2022
- Tailored SiO2‐TiO2 Aerogel/Ag Flexible Films as Stable SERS Substrates for Hazardous Materials DetectionAdvanced Materials Technologies, 2021
- Applications of Carbon Dots (CDs) in Latent Fingerprints ImagingChemistry – An Asian Journal, 2021
- Synthesis of gold nanoparticles using Crinum macowanii bulb extracts and the application of these materials in blood detections at crime scenesLuminescence, 2019
- HPLC for Pharmaceutical Scientists2006