Abstract
Among the many complex issues sparked by the desire of postcommunist countries to join the European Union are those surrounding the roles of memory and history. Yellow Star, Red Star: Holocaust Remembrance after Communism is a deep and impassioned book that analyzes the development of Holocaust remembrance in three postcommunist countries. At the same time, Jelena Subotić examines how each country sought to incorporate the memory of communism’s crimes into European consciousness. Considerable literature on each of these issues exists separately, and indeed John-Paul Himka’s and Joanna Beata Michlic’s edited volume Bringing the Dark Past to Light: The Reception of the Holocaust in Postcommunist Europe (2019) offers twenty chapters on precisely this topic. Subotić’s unique contribution is to present her three case studies within a theoretical framework that helps make sense of the strategy. Applying the concept of “memory appropriation,” Subotić argues that many postcommunist countries used Holocaust remembrance as a dual line of attack to address Western requirements for entry to the European Union while simultaneously representing the suffering of the Jews as their own under communism or from other ethnic groups. In that way, Holocaust remembrance “ceases to be about the Holocaust at all, and is instead about the very acute legitimacy needs of postcommunist states which are building their identity as fundamentally anticommunist, which then in turn makes them more legitimately European” (10).