Comparing the Validity of Different Sources of Information on Emergency Department Visits
Authors:
- Nandini DendukuriNDNandini Dendukuri
- Jane McCuskerJMJane McCusker
- François BellavanceFBFrançois Bellavance
- Sylvie CardinSCSylvie Cardin
- Josée VerdonJVJosée Verdon
- Igor KarpIKIgor Karp
- Eric BelzileEBEric Belzile
- 1 March 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Medical Care
- Vol. 43 (3) , 266-275
Abstract
Emergency department (ED) use in Quebec may be measured from varied sources, eg, patient's self-reports, hospital medical charts, and provincial health insurance claims databases. Determining the relative validity of each source is complicated because none is a gold standard. We sought to compare the validity of different measures of ED use without arbitrarily assuming one is perfect. Data were obtained from a nursing liaison intervention study for frail seniors visiting EDs at 4 university-affiliated hospitals in Montreal. The number of ED visits during 2 consecutive follow-up periods of 1 and 4 months after baseline was obtained from patient interviews, from medical charts of participating hospitals, and from the provincial health insurance claims database. Latent class analysis was used to estimate the validity of each source. The impact of the following covariates on validity was evaluated: hospital visited, patient's demographic/clinical characteristics, risk of functional decline, nursing liaison intervention, duration of recall, previous ED use, and previous hospitalization. The patient's self-report was found to be the least accurate (sensitivity: 70%, specificity: 88%). Claims databases had the greatest validity, especially after defining claims made on consecutive days as part of the same ED visit (sensitivity: 98%, specificity: 98%). The validity of the medical chart was intermediate. Lower sensitivity (or under-reporting) on the self-report appeared to be associated with higher age, low comorbidity and shorter length of recall. The claims database is the most valid method of measuring ED use among seniors in Quebec compared with hospital medical charts and patient-reported use.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Agreement between Self‐reported and Routinely Collected Health‐care Utilization Data among SeniorsHealth Services Research, 2002
- Validity of self reported utilisation of primary health care services in an urban population in SpainJournal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 2000
- Health Services Utilization Reporting in Respiratory PatientsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1998
- Comparison of self-reported and medical record health care utilization measuresJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1996
- The Validity of Survey Data on Utilization of Health and Social Services Among the Very OldJournal of Gerontology, 1994
- The Short Form of the Geriatric Depression Scale: A Comparison With the 30-Item FormJournal of Geriatric Psychiatry and Neurology, 1991
- Evaluating Diagnostic Tests with Imperfect StandardsAmerican Journal of Clinical Pathology, 1990
- Estimation of test error rates, disease prevalence and relative risk from misclassified data: a reviewJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1988
- The Validity of Self-reported Physician Utilization MeasuresMedical Care, 1984
- Validation of a short Orientation-Memory-Concentration Test of cognitive impairmentAmerican Journal of Psychiatry, 1983