Abstract
Objectives: Neck of femur (NOF) fractures are a common and clinically significant presentation within paramedic practice, yet Australian paramedics currently manage these patients without dedicated evidence-informed pre-hospital guidelines. Previous quantitative research has identified variability in assessment and management practices, suggesting uncertainty surrounding care. This study explored how Australian paramedics perceive and navigate the pre-hospital management of suspected NOF fractures. Methods: An exploratory qualitative design was undertaken using eight online focus groups with 21 registered paramedics, recruited from a preceding national survey. Discussions followed a semi-structured interview guide and were conducted via Zoom, audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim and analysed using the framework method. Analysis was iterative and interpretive, with themes developed through sustained engagement with the data and reflexive discussion amongst the research team. Results: Four themes were identified: (1) balancing rapid assessment with diagnostic uncertainty; (2) managing immediate care amid competing priorities and limited information; (3) sources, strengths and limitations of the existing knowledge base; and (4) envisioning clearer, evidence-informed guidance for future practice. Participants described NOF fracture care as shaped by uncertainty, experiential learning and contextual judgement rather than standardised guidance. Decision-making extended beyond clinical assessment alone to include ethical and patient-centred considerations regarding movement, communication, dignity and analgesia. Participants frequently described relying on tacit knowledge, peer learning and accumulated clinical experience to guide care in the absence of condition-specific pre-hospital guidance. Discussion revealed a shared perception that clearer evidence-informed guidance could support greater consistency, confidence and patient-centred care. Conclusions: Australian paramedics describe NOF fracture management as a complex and interpretive practice shaped by uncertainty, experience and contextual decision-making. In the absence of dedicated guidance, paramedics rely heavily on experiential and relational forms of knowledge to navigate care. These findings highlight the need for evidence-informed pre-hospital guidance and educational support for NOF fracture management that better reflects the realities and complexities of paramedic practice.

This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit: