Abstract
Rationale: Within the last decade, applications of compound‐specific stable isotope analysis of nitrogen (δ 15 N values) in amino acids (CSIA‐AA) have developed rapidly, particularly within organismal ecology. Unlike with bulk stable isotope analysis (BSIA), the reproducibility of δ 15 N‐AA measurements has not been critically assessed. Two primary concerns include the diversity of techniques available for the derivatization of amino acids prior to analysis by gas chromatography/combustion/isotope ratio mass spectrometry (GC/C/IRMS) and the myriad of standardization practices and quality assurance procedures used across studies. Methods: We examined the relative effect of three normalization procedures, (1) internal reference calibration, (2) compound‐specific calibration, and (3) scale‐normalization, on the accuracy and precision of δ 15 N‐AA measurements by GC/C/IRMS and the comparability of δ 15 N‐AA measurements by two derivatization techniques, methoxycarbonylation‐esterification and acetylation‐esterification, across a range of organisms. Results: The overall accuracy and precision of δ 15 N‐AA measurements were improved following both compound‐specific calibration and scale‐normalization, as was the comparability of δ 15 N‐AA measurements of individual amino acids between derivatization techniques across organisms. The mean difference of scale‐normalized δ 15 N‐AA values across all organisms between the two derivatization techniques was 0.19‰, much less than the typical analytical error associated with δ 15 N‐AA measurements (±1‰) . Conclusions: Adoption of standardized calibration procedures will be important to establishing reproducibility in δ 15 N‐AA measurements, particularly across derivatization techniques. It is both technically practical and desirable for users of CSIA‐AA to adopt practices in quality control and assessment similar to those outlined for BSIA, including the compound‐specific calibration of δ 15 N‐AA values, followed by scale‐normalization. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit: