Effects of First Language on Second Language Writing: Translation versus Direct Composition*
Authors:
- 1 June 1992
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Language Learning
- Vol. 42 (2) , 183-209
Abstract
This study of English compositions written by 48 Japanese university students examined: (1) differences between the texts resulting from two writing processes, one writing first in Japanese and then translating into English and the other composing directly in English and (2) the relationship between these two writing processes and students’ language proficiency. In terms of quality of content, organization, and style, lower‐level writers tended to benefit from translation, whereas higher‐level writers did not benefit much. Overall, syntactic complexity was greater in translations than in direct writings. In terms of error frequency, higher‐level students tended to make more errors that interfered with intended meaning in translation than in direct writing, but lower‐level students did not show any difference. Regarding the correlation between language proficiency and the quality of the writing resulting from the two composing processes, oral skills related more closely to writing quality than did grammar knowledge, particularly for direct writing.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Managing the Complexity of Revising across LanguagesTESOL Quarterly, 1990
- Writing Expertise and Second‐Language Proficiency*Language Learning, 1989
- Six writers in search of texts: A protocol-based study of L1 and L2 writingELT Journal, 1987
- Language Proficiency, Writing Ability, and Composing Strategies: A Study of ESL College Student Writers*Language Learning, 1987
- The Effects of Referential Questions on ESL Classroom DiscourseTESOL Quarterly, 1986
- Rhetorical Patterns in English and JapaneseTESOL Quarterly, 1984
- An Analysis of Published Tests of Writing ProficiencyEducational Measurement: Issues and Practice, 1983
- Writing in A Bilingual Program: The Relation of L1 and L2 TextsTESOL Quarterly, 1982
- Language and Thought: Effect of Translation vs InterpretationTESOL Quarterly, 1979
- CULTURAL THOUGHT PATTERNS IN INTER‐CULTURAL EDUCATIONLanguage Learning, 1966