Reproducibility of health claims in meta-analysis studies of COVID quarantine (stay-at-home) orders
Authors:
- S. Stanley YoungSYS. Stanley Young
- Warren B. KindzierskiWarren B. Kindzierski
Preprint
Abstract
The coronavirus pandemic (COVID) has been an extraordinary test of modern government scientific procedures that inform and shape policy. Many governments implemented COVID quarantine (stay-at-home) orders on the notion that this nonpharmaceutical intervention would delay and flatten the epidemic peak and largely benefit public health outcomes. The overall research capacity response to COVID since late 2019 has been massive. Given lack of research transparency, only a small fraction of published research has been judged by others to be reproducible before COVID. Independent evaluation of published meta-analysis on a common research question can be used to assess the reproducibility of a claim coming from that field of research. We used a p-value plotting statistical method to independently evaluate reproducibility of specific research claims made in four meta-analysis studies related to benefits/risks of COVID quarantine orders. Outcomes we investigated included: mortality, mental health symptoms, incidence of domestic violence, and suicidal ideation (thoughts of killing yourself). Three of the four meta-analyses that we evaluated (mortality, mental health symptoms, incidence of domestic violence) raise further questions about benefits/risks of this form of intervention. The fourth meta-analysis study (suicidal ideation) is unreliable. Given lack of research transparency and irreproducibility of published research, independent evaluation of meta-analysis studies using p-value plotting is offered as a way to strengthen or refute (falsify) claims made in COVID research.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Suicidal ideation and suicide attempts in psychiatric patients during the COVID-19: A systematic review and meta-analysisPsychiatry Research, 2022
- Domestic violence during the COVID-19 pandemic - Evidence from a systematic review and meta-analysisJournal of Criminal Justice, 2021
- Peripandemic psychiatric emergencies: impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on patients according to diagnostic subgroupEuropean Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience, 2021
- The psychological impact of COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns: a review and meta-analysis of longitudinal studies and natural experimentsPsychological Medicine, 2021
- Drivers of COVID-19 Stay at Home Orders: Epidemiologic, Economic, or Political Concerns?Economics of Disasters and Climate Change, 2020
- Quality and reproducibility during the COVID-19 pandemicJHEP Reports, 2020
- How did “flatten the curve” become “flatten the economy?” A perspective from the United States of AmericaAsian Journal of Psychiatry, 2020
- Lockdown or LockupDisaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness, 2020
- Responding to Covid‐19: How to Navigate a Public Health Emergency Legally and EthicallyHastings Center Report, 2020
- Increasing value and reducing waste in research design, conduct, and analysisThe Lancet, 2014