A review of case studies publishing in Management Decision 2003‐2004
- 1 July 2005
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Management Decision
- Vol. 43 (6) , 851-876
Abstract
Purpose: This paper aims to specify a set of methodological stages to conduct case studies. It presents a graphical representation of these stages, describes how it assists management researchers to build theory from data gathered in the field, and outlines its value for achieving sound management research.Design/methodology/approach: A sample of nine cases published in Management Decision within the last two years (2003‐2004) is selected in order to illustrate these processes.Findings: The paper's major contribution to research methodology is to specify a set of guidelines for conducting case studies and being explicit in how to apply a series of quality criteria for evaluating case studies in practice. The proposal not only helps to conduct research, but also documents the links between the research topics (in the conceptual framework), data (observations and interpretations in the field), data analysis (coding using the concepts in the conceptual framework and emergent themes) and the theory and knowledge accumulated through the research process.Practical implications: The increasing use of case studies in management, and the desire to build theory from qualitative data, has highlighted a gap between existing proposals and the criteria for rigorous case studies. This contribution helps to close this gap by providing guidelines and the practical application of the quality principles. It assists management researchers working in these paradigms to build theory from qualitative data.Originality/value: The proposal adds to the tools that management researchers can follow to produce sound research. This paper illustrates several case studies in order to show their epistemological approach, and to evaluate their quality level by applying our principles.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Identifying key knowledge area in the professional services industry: a case studyJournal of Knowledge Management, 2004
- The Cuban missile crisis: strategy formulation in actionManagement Decision, 2004
- Organizational citizenship behavior: a case study of culture, leadership and trustManagement Decision, 2004
- Exploring the current practice of visioning: case studies from the UK financial services sectorManagement Decision, 2003
- Information use in strategic decision makingManagement Decision, 2003
- Pre‐alliance planning: development of an information system infrastructure to support strategic alliance activitiesManagement Decision, 2003
- Managing radical organisational transformationManagement Decision, 2003
- The Future of Grounded TheoryQualitative Health Research, 1999
- A Set of Principles for Conducting and Evaluating Interpretive Field Studies in Information Systems1MIS Quarterly, 1999
- Qualitative research: meanings or practices?Information Systems Journal, 1998