Health systems governance, shocks and resilience: a scoping review of key concepts and theories
Open Access
- 19 June 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Global Health
- Vol. 10 (6) , e017358
Abstract
Introduction: It is often argued that health system resilience to shocks is influenced by governance. Multiple theoretical perspectives seemed to have emerged in the literature, but there has been limited analysis of their foundation and implications so far. To address this gap, the aim of this paper is to carry out a scoping review of conceptualisation and theories on the definition and relationship between governance and health system resilience in the context of shocks. Methods: Six electronic databases were searched using the following keywords: resilience, health system, framework and governance. 835 abstracts were screened, and 47 full texts were extracted and analysed in MAXQDA using inductively generated codes. We analysed the conceptualisation of health system resilience, governance and shock and theories on the relationship between them. Results: Although there are no collectively agreed definitions, health system resilience is typically defined as the capacity of a system to continue to perform its fundamental functions in the setting of acute disruptive events (shocks). Existing conceptualisations and theories focus on normative descriptions of the ‘capacities’ that should be developed to promote health system resilience. They usually emphasise the bidirectional relationship between governance and health system resilience, but underlying mechanisms remain undertheorised. While many authors stress the value of a forward-looking approach that anticipates scenarios to build resilience, there is no consensus on whether a centralised ‘top-down’ is more effective than a decentralised ‘bottom-up’ approach to respond to shocks. Conclusions: Overall, the literature suggests that governance is critical to understanding health system resilience in response to shocks, yet these relationships are considered complex and potentially bidirectional and remain undertheorised. Future research should develop more nuanced theories that capture the dynamics of these relationships and consider how the health system relates to broader (non-health) systems that have the potential to foster health system resilience.Keywords
Funding Information
- Mauricio Avendano and Nolwenn Bühler are funded by the Swiss National science Foundation programme (PNR80). (210142)
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Framing and the formation of global health prioritiesThe Lancet, 2022
- 2.C. Round table: COVID-19 - strengthening governance for health and health systems resilienceEuropean Journal of Public Health, 2021
- Health systems resilience in managing the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons from 28 countriesNature Medicine, 2021
- Health system resilience to extreme weather events in Asia-Pacific: a scoping reviewClimate and Development, 2021
- Health system resilience: a literature review of empirical researchHealth Policy and Planning, 2020
- Understanding the Resilience of Health Systems2020
- Conceptual analysis of health systems resilience: A scoping reviewSocial Science & Medicine, 2019
- Health systems resilience: meaningful construct or catchphrase?The Lancet, 2017
- What is a resilient health system? Lessons from EbolaThe Lancet, 2015
- Causes of the Russian mortality crisis: Evidence and interpretationsWorld Development, 1998