Gerrymandering and Compactness: Implementation Flexibility and Abuse
- 16 December 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Political Analysis
- Vol. 29 (4) , 448-466
Abstract
Political districts may be drawn to favor one group or political party over another, or gerrymandered. A number of measurements have been suggested as ways to detect and prevent such behavior. These measures give concrete axes along which districts and districting plans can be compared. However, measurement values are affected by both noise and the compounding effects of seemingly innocuous implementation decisions. Such issues will arise for any measure. As a case study demonstrating the effect, we show that commonly used measures of geometric compactness for district boundaries are affected by several factors irrelevant to fairness or compliance with civil rights law. We further show that an adversary could manipulate measurements to affect the assessment of a given plan. This instability complicates using these measurements as legislative or judicial standards to counteract unfair redistricting practices. This paper accompanies the release of packages in C++, Python, and R that correctly, efficiently, and reproducibly calculate a variety of compactness scores.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- XSEDE: Accelerating Scientific DiscoveryComputing in Science & Engineering, 2014
- The case for open computer programsNature, 2012
- Computational science: ...ErrorNature, 2010
- Publish your computer code: it is good enoughNature, 2010
- A Measure of BizarrenessQuarterly Journal of Political Science, 2010
- Why Most Published Research Findings Are FalsePLOS Medicine, 2005
- Fast and Robust Smallest Enclosing Balls1999
- What every computer scientist should know about floating-point arithmeticACM Computing Surveys, 1991
- Measuring Compactness and the Role of a Compactness Standard in a Test for Partisan and Racial GerrymanderingThe Journal of Politics, 1990
- A Low-Error Conformal Map Projection for the 50 StatesThe American Cartographer, 1984