Abstract
Summary: For over six decades, regulatory agencies have asserted that asbestos is readily resuspended by indoor activities such as walking and sweeping. Numerous aerosol physicists have challenged this claim, arguing that, based on fundamental particle adhesion theory, resuspension is unlikely, particularly for biologically relevant fibers. To empirically evaluate this discrepancy between theoretical predictions and practical observations, chrysotile fibers were uniformly distributed on an epoxy-coated concrete floor. A volunteer performed two representative disturbance scenarios: walking and sweeping, conducted on a 3 × 3-m test area. Fiber surface loadings were measured to be 2.9 × 10 11 and 2.6 × 10 11 fibers for the walking and sweeping trials, respectively. Airborne fibers were sampled and characterized across a spectrum of widths and lengths, including fibers as short as 0.5 μm and up to 74 μm, with a range of aspect ratios. Particular attention was given to OSHA-classified fibers (≥5 μm in length: ≥3:1 aspect ratio). The resuspension efficiency of these fibers was found to be exceedingly low under both disturbance conditions. Despite the presence of nearly 300 billion fibers on the surface, about 0.0001% were resuspended. Resuspended fibers were further grouped by size class, and results were interpreted considering aerosol theoretical models emphasizing the role of surface area-to-volume (SA-V) ratio in fiber adhesion and detachment dynamics. These findings are consistent with longstanding aerosol science predictions that emphasize the strong adhesion of elongated, high SA-V fibers to flat indoor surfaces. Notably, while previous studies, including those conducted after the World Trade Center collapsed, have observed similar behavior, their implications have not been integrated into policy or exposure modeling. This appears to be the first study to quantitatively confirm the relationship between fiber morphology and resuspension potential. It also puts into question the hundreds of claims of the past twenty years of litigation alleging asbestos-related disease with take home exposure.