Evaluation of fecal indicator bacteria concentration in different water sources, storage treatments, and holding times
Open Access
- 1 July 2026
- journal article
- technical report
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Environmental Quality
- Vol. 55 (4) , e70233
Abstract
Accurate water quality monitoring of microbial indicators hinges on understanding the impact of holding times and treatments on water sample results. This study examined interacting factors influencing holding times for fecal indicator bacteria (FIB) in water samples held for a range of times (0–216 h) under three storage treatments (i.e., Controlled Cold [∼4°C], Controlled Ambient [∼21°C], and Changing Conditions [∼4°C–21°C]). Four separate trials were conducted during 2016 using two distinct water supplies: river water ( n = 2) and post‐irrigation canal water ( n = 2). Large carboys of water ( n = 3/trial, ∼53L) were evenly divided into 500 mL aliquots for storage under different treatments ( n = 105/treatment). Samples were processed in triplicate using standard membrane filtration for Escherichia coli and fecal coliforms. Linear regression with autocorrelation and Dunnett's test were used to analyze the concentration of FIB across holding times from baseline ( T = 0). Canal water samples maintained FIB concentrations similar to T = 0 for at least 72 h under Controlled Cold; at least 48 h under Changing Conditions, and at least 30 h under Controlled Ambient treatments. By contrast, river water samples maintained concentrations similar to T = 0 at least 180 h without statistically significant changes under Controlled Cold, at least 72 h under Changing Conditions, and at least 36 h under Controlled Ambient treatments. Regardless of the treatments, river water samples were more stable than canal water samples, likely due to starting conditions. Holding times for water quality monitoring continues to be a multifaceted challenge and may warrant further exploration or more flexibility around regulatory requirements.Keywords
Funding Information
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration (#U01003‐572)
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Spatiotemporal Variability in Microbial Quality of Western US Agricultural Water Supplies: A Multistate StudyJournal of Environmental Quality, 2018
- Spatial and temporal variability of bacterial indicators and pathogens in six California reservoirs during extreme droughtWater Research, 2018
- Monitoring bacterial indicators of water quality in a tidally influenced delta: A Sisyphean pursuitScience of The Total Environment, 2017
- Multistate Evaluation of Microbial Water and Sediment Quality from Agricultural Recovery BasinsJournal of Environmental Quality, 2016
- Comparison of two methods for detection of fecal indicator bacteria used in water quality monitoring of the Three Gorges ReservoirJournal of Environmental Sciences, 2015
- Escherichia coli survival in waters: Temperature dependenceWater Research, 2013
- Survival of Escherichia coli in the environment: fundamental and public health aspectsThe ISME Journal, 2010
- Effects of temperature and sand on E. coli survival in a northern lake water microcosmJournal of Water and Health, 2006
- Membrane filter method for enumerating Escherichia coliApplied and Environmental Microbiology, 1981
- Effect of storage temperature and time on the coliforms in water samplesWater Research, 1967