Abstract
The long-acknowledged gap between catalogued and actual marine biodiversity has been widening recently, as many morphologically defined taxa are being revealed as complexes of genetically distinct cryptic lineages, highlighting that species diversity based on morphology is often underestimated. To evaluate the extent of this underestimation, we focus on the Mediterranean molluscan class Polyplacophora, which displays an ancient evolutionary history and a stable morphology-based taxonomy. We applied an integrative taxonomic approach to a dataset of 766 specimens assigned to 21 morphospecies, representing half of the diversity in the area. Our goal was to detect cryptic species, estimate their frequency, and evaluate their impact on estimates of the extant Mediterranean polyplacophoran diversity. The integrative approach recognised 40 putative species, uncovering extensive cryptic diversity within our sample and suggesting that Mediterranean chiton diversity is substantially underestimated. We extrapolated the Cryptic Diversity Index (CDi) of the evaluated species (the number of cryptic species delimited within a taxon) to the unassayed Mediterranean polyplacophoran taxa using two resampling strategies. The projections of the extant Mediterranean species, including cryptic diversity, yielded 1.64–2.24 or 1.29–2.24 times the current estimates. The bearing of cryptic species was then also applied to the European and worldwide extant and fossil faunas, and hundreds of undiagnosed species were predicted. Our estimates for cryptic species diversity in polyplacophorans are on the lower bound of the ranges proposed for arthropods based on a review of the literature (2–6). Even so, generalising these figures would mean that every species could be part of a complex of at least two cryptic species.