Medical and Veterinary Studentsʼ Structural Knowledge of Pulmonary Physiology Concepts
Authors:
- William C. McGaghieWMWilliam C. McGaghie
- Donald R. McCrimmonDMDonald R. McCrimmon
- Jason A. ThompsonJTJason A. Thompson
- Michael M. RavitchMRMichael M. Ravitch
- Gordon MitchellGMGordon Mitchell
- 1 April 2000
- journal article
- educating physicians
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Academic Medicine
- Vol. 75 (4) , 362-368
Abstract
Purpose The goal of this study was to assess quantitatively medical and veterinary students' knowledge structures of 12 pulmonary physiology concepts before and after receiving a focused instructional block. The “goodness of fit” and internal consistency reliability of the students' knowledge structures were evaluated. Indexes of the students' structural knowledge were correlated with customary measures of student learning of the same concepts. Method Knowledge structures were assessed using a questionnaire that requested similarity judgments about all possible pairs of the concepts: n(n − 1)/2 = 66 pairs. The similarity judgment data were analyzed using the individual differences (INDSCAL) model of multidimensional scaling (MDS). Dimension weights for individual students were then correlated with their final examination scores. Results A four-dimensional MDS solution provided the best structural fit to the pairwise concept-similarity data. Dimension 1 ranges from control of breathing to lung gas exchange. Dimension 2 ranges from control of breathing to respiratory mechanics. Dimension 3 separates perfusion from diffusion. Dimension 4 addresses ventilatory control. Hierarchical concept clusters are located within this framework. However, indexes of structural learning did not correlate with other measures of knowledge about the same concepts. Conclusion The study outcomes, in contrast to research in other fields, suggest that structural knowledge in this domain differs from knowledge assessed by standard examinations. Further research involving other basic science or clinical concept sets is needed to verify or refute this finding.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Concept Mapping to Facilitate Veterinary Students' Understanding of Fluid and Electrolyte DisordersTeaching and Learning in Medicine, 1998
- Structural representations in knowledge acquisition.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1994
- Structural knowledge assessment: Comparison of referent structures.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1994
- Concept maps and the development of cases for problem-based learning [published erratum appears in Acad Med 1994 Mar;69(3):193]Academic Medicine, 1994
- Hypothesis Generation and the Coordination of Theory and Evidence in Novice Diagnostic ReasoningMedical Decision Making, 1993
- Pedagogical Knowledge Structures in Prospective Teachers: Relationships to Performance in a Teaching Methodology CourseResearch Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 1993
- ON THE NATURE OF COGNITIVE MAPSJournal of Management Studies, 1992
- Meaningful Learning in College Biology through Concept MappingThe American Biology Teacher, 1991
- Assessing structural knowledge.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1991
- Factors influencing the learning of classical mechanicsAmerican Journal of Physics, 1980