How do I peer-review a scientific article?—a personal perspective
Author:
- 1 February 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by AME Publishing Company in Annals of Translational Medicine
- Vol. 6 (3) , 68
Abstract
Peer-review is an essential activity for the vast majority of credited scientific journals and represents the cornerstone for assessing the quality of potential publications, since it is substantially aimed to identify drawbacks or inaccuracies that may flaw the outcome or the presentation of scientific research. Since the importance of this activity is seldom underestimated by some referees, the purpose of this article is to present a personal and arbitrary perspective on how a scientific article should be peer-reviewed, offering a tentative checklist aimed to describe the most important criteria that should be considered. These basically include accepting the assignment only when the topic is in accordance with referee’s background, disclosing potential conflicts of interest, checking availability and time according to size and complexity of the article, identifying the innovative value of the manuscript, providing exhaustive and clear comments, expressing disagreement with a fair and balanced approach, weighting revisions according to the importance of the journal, summarizing recommendations according to previous comments, maintaining confidentiality throughout and after the peer-review process. I really hope that some notions reported in this dissertation may be a guide or a help, especially for young scientists, who are willing to be engaged in peer-review activity for scientific journals.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- How do I write a scientific article?—A personal perspectiveAnnals of Translational Medicine, 2017
- Living legend in clinical biochemistry—Prof. Giuseppe Lippi: we should have strength to stick to things we doAnnals of Translational Medicine, 2016
- Routine check for plagiarismCellular and Molecular Life Sciences, 2015
- Best peer reviewers and the quality of peer review in biomedical journalsCroatian Medical Journal, 2012
- How to Select a Journal to Submit and Publish Your Biomedical Paper?2012
- Peer Review: Publication’s Gold Standard2012
- Biomedical research platforms and their influence on article submissions and journal rankings: An updateBiochemia Medica, 2012
- Detection of duplicates and redundancies. A major responsibility of peer-reviewers?Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (CCLM), 2008
- Editorial peer review for improving the quality of reports of biomedical studiesCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2007