Many years ago, Hugo Benioff proposed describing earthquake size with energy. It never took hold in part because we could never agree just how much energy is released. I have hoped that seismic moment could deliver us from The Scale. It has everything a scientist could love, a physical reality that connects field geology to geodesy to seismology. Just tell them the moment and we won't have to explain that this earthquake is really much larger than that other earthquake, even though M 7 does not seem that much more than M 5. But deliverance has not come. We seismologists all cling to The Scale even though calculating seismic moments is now routine. The first thing we do with a seismic moment is use it to calculate a moment magnitude, and we are back where we started, without units, saying, “Well, actually the energy goes up as the square root of 1,000....” What is this power that The Scale holds over us?