Why Self-Report Measures of Self-Control and Inhibition Tasks Do Not Substantially Correlate
Open Access
- 1 January 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by University of California Press in Collabra: Psychology
- Vol. 6 (1)
Abstract
Trait self-control is often defined as the ability to inhibit dominant responses including thoughts, emotions, and behavioral impulses. Despite the pivotal role of inhibition for trait self-control, a growing body of evidence found small-to-zero correlations between self-report measures of trait self-control and behavioral inhibition tasks. These observations seem puzzling considering that both types of measures are often seen as operationalizations of the same or at least closely related theoretical constructs. Previous explanations for this non-correspondence focused on psychometric properties of the measures. Here, we discuss three further factors that may explain the empirical non-correspondence between trait self-control scales and behavioral inhibition tasks: (1) the distinction between typical and maximum performance, (2) the measurement of single versus repeated performance, and (3) differences between impulses in different domains. Specifically, we argue that a) self-report measures of trait self-control are designed to assess typical performance, and relative to these, behavioral inhibition tasks are designed to assess maximum performance; b) self-report measures of trait self-control capture central tendencies of aggregates of many different instances of behavior, whereas behavioral inhibition tasks are momentary, one-time state measures; and c) most self-report measures of trait self-control are designed to measure general, cross-domain inhibition, whereas behavioral inhibition tasks also measure narrower, domain-specific inhibition to a substantial degree. In conclusion, we argue that it is implausible to hypothesize more than a low correlation between self-report measures of trait self-control and behavioral inhibition tasks as they genuinely focus on different aspects of the theoretical construct of self-control. We also discuss the broader implications of these issues for self-control as a theoretical construct and its appropriate measurement.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Nature and Organization of Individual Differences in Executive FunctionsCurrent Directions in Psychological Science, 2012
- A meta-analysis of the convergent validity of self-control measuresJournal of Research in Personality, 2011
- Assessing the Outcomes of Spine Surgery Using Global Positioning SystemsSpine, 2011
- A gradient of childhood self-control predicts health, wealth, and public safetyProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2011
- Are personality and behavioral measures of impulse control convergent or distinct predictors of health behaviors?Journal of Research in Personality, 2009
- Back to the future: Personality and Assessment and personality developmentJournal of Research in Personality, 2009
- Sociogenomic Personality PsychologyJournal of Personality, 2008
- Moving Personality Beyond the Person-Situation DebateCurrent Directions in Psychological Science, 2004
- Toward a structure- and process-integrated view of personality: Traits as density distributions of states.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2001
- Relations between measures of typical and maximum job performance.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1988