Never quite right: Identity factors contributing to bias and discrimination experienced by women leaders in the United States
- 19 November 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Development Quarterly
- Vol. 36 (4) , 367-386
Abstract
While much bias and discrimination research has focused on individual identity analysis, for example, gender, race, or ethnicity, what is not fully understood is how other social categories of difference influence discrimination. Using qualitative content analysis, this study examines facets of women leaders' identity that influence their experiences of bias. Respondents were 913 women in four United States industries in which top leadership roles are male dominated but the industries overall are female dominated or gender balanced. The findings revealed 30 distinct identity factors that were used as the basis for discrimination. The variety of the factors and the variation of stigma within each factor show that women leaders are considered “never quite right” as almost any facet of their identity can be declared problematic for a specific woman in a specific context. Human resource leaders should create inclusive policies so that women can express their authentic selves at work. Leadership teams and supervisors should be trained to recognize identity factors that may be the focus of criticism and, thus, serve as veiled bases for discrimination.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Beyond the Baby Bump: Subtle Discrimination Against Working Mothers In the Hiring ProcessJournal of Business and Psychology, 2022
- Representation of Women in the Leadership Structure of the US Health Care SystemJAMA Network Open, 2021
- Measuring the invisible: Development and multi‐industry validation of the Gender Bias Scale for Women LeadersHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 2020
- Diversity improves performance and outcomesJournal of the National Medical Association, 2019
- Experiences of women veterans within the private sector: Examining the intersection of gender and veteran statusHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 2019
- A feminist poststructuralist critique of talent management: Toward a more gender sensitive body of knowledgeBRQ Business Research Quarterly, 2019
- Appearing self‐confident and getting credit for it: Why it may be easier for men than women to gain influence at workHuman Resource Management, 2017
- Making the Invisible Visible: A Cross‐Sector Analysis of Gender‐Based Leadership BarriersHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 2016
- Effectiveness of radio spokesperson's gender, vocal pitch and accent and the use of music in radio advertisingBRQ Business Research Quarterly, 2015
- Is Fat a Feminist Issue? Exploring the Gendered Nature of Weight BiasSex Roles, 2011