A Differential Clinical Benefit Examination of Full Lumbar Endoscopy vs Interspinous Process Spacers in the Treatment of Spinal Stenosis: An Effect Size Meta-Analysis of Clinical Outcomes
Authors:
- 16 February 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by International Journal of Spine Surgery in International Journal of Spine Surgery
- Vol. 16 (1) , 102-123
Abstract
Study Design A design-agnostic standardized effect meta-analysis of 48 randomized, prospective, and retrospective studies on clinical outcomes with spinal endoscopic and interspinous process spacer (IPS) surgery. Objective The study aimed to provide reference set of Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) and visual analog scale (VAS) effect size data for back and leg pain following endoscopic and IPS decompression for lumbar herniated disc, foraminal, or lateral recess spinal stenosis. Background Mechanical low back pain following endoscopic transforaminal decompression may be more reliably reduced by simultaneous posterior column stabilization with IPS. Methods A systematic search of the PubMed, EMBASE, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials from 1 January 2000 to 2 April 2020, identified 880 eligible endoscopy and 362 IPS studies varying in design and metrics. The authors compared calculated standardized effect sizes (Cohen’s d) for extracted ODI, VAS-back, and VAS-leg data. Results The pooled standardized effect size combining the ODI, VAS-back, and VAS-leg data for the total sample of 19862 data sets from the 30 endoscopy and 18 IPS was 0.877 (95% CI = 0.857–0.898). When stratified by surgery, the combined effect sizes were 0.877 (95% CI = 0.849–0.905) for endoscopic decompression and 0.863 (95% CI = 0.796–0.930; P = 0.056) for IPS implantation. The ODI effect sizes calculated on 6462 samples with directly visualized endoscopic decompression were 0.917 (95% CI = 0.891–0.943) versus 0.798 (95% CI = 0.713–0.883; P < 0.001) with indirect IPS decompression (P < 0.001). The VAS-back effect sizes calculated on 3672 samples were 0.661 (95% CI = 0.585–0.738) for endoscopy and 0.784 (95% CI: 0.644–0.923; P = 0.187) for IPS. The VAS-leg effect sizes calculated on 7890 samples were 0.885 (95% CI = 0.852–0.917) for endoscopic decompression and 0.851 (95% CI = 0.767–0.935; P = 0.427). Conclusion Lumbar IPS implantation produces larger reduction in low back pain than spinal endoscopy. On the basis of this meta-analysis, the combination of lumbar transforaminal endoscopy with simultaneous IPS has merits and should be formally investigated in higher grade clinical studies. Clinical Relevance Meta-analysis on the added clinical benefit of combining lumbar endoscopic decompression with an interspinous process spacer. Level of Evidence 2.Keywords
This publication has 173 references indexed in Scilit:
- Lumbar spinal stenosis treatment with aperius perclid interspinous systemEuropean Spine Journal, 2012
- Interspinous Spacer Implant in Patients with Lumbar Spinal Stenosis: Preliminary Results of a Multicenter, Randomized, Controlled TrialPain Research and Treatment, 2012
- Effectiveness of interspinous implant surgery in patients with intermittent neurogenic claudication: a systematic review and meta-analysisEuropean Spine Journal, 2011
- Long-term reduction in pain and disability after surgery with the interspinous device for intervertebral assisted motion (DIAM) spinal stabilization system in patients with low back pain: 4-year follow-up from a longitudinal prospective case seriesEuropean Spine Journal, 2011
- Safety and efficacy of a new percutaneously implantable interspinous process deviceActa Neurochirurgica, 2010
- Higher risk of dural tears and recurrent herniation with lumbar micro-endoscopic discectomyEuropean Spine Journal, 2010
- Does an interspinous device (Coflex™) improve the outcome of decompressive surgery in lumbar spinal stenosis? One-year follow up of a prospective case control study of 60 patientsEuropean Spine Journal, 2009
- The short- and mid-term effect of dynamic interspinous distraction in the treatment of recurrent lumbar facet joint painEuropean Spine Journal, 2009
- Interspinous implants (X Stop®, Wallis®, Diam®) for the treatment of LSS: is there a correlation between radiological parameters and clinical outcome?European Spine Journal, 2009
- Measurement of health statusControlled Clinical Trials, 1989