Should forest regeneration studies have more replications?
Authors:
Open Access
Abstract
When it comes to testing for differences in seedling survival, researchers sometimes make a Type II statistical error (i.e. failure to reject a false null hypothesis) due to the inherent variability associated with survival in tree planting studies. For example, in one trial (with five replications) first-year survival of seedlings planted in October (42%) was not significantly different (alpha = 0.05) from those planted in December (69%). Did planting in a dry October truly have no effect on survival? Authors who make a Type II error might not be aware that as seedling survival decreases (down to an overall average of 50% survival), statistical power declines. As a result, the ability to declare an 8% difference as “significant†is very difficult when survival averages 90% or less. We estimate that about half of regeneration trials (average survival of pines <90%) cannot declare a 12% difference as statistically significant (alpha = 0.05). When researchers realize their tree planting trials have low statistical power, they should consider using more replications. Other ways to increase power include: (1) use a one-tailed test (2) use a potentially more powerful contrast test (instead of an overall treatment F-test) and (3) conduct survival trials under a roof.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Determining the effects of felling method and season of year on the regeneration of short rotation coppiceInternational Journal of Forest Engineering, 2015
- Planting Deep Increases Early Survival and Growth of Pinus echinata SeedlingsThe Open Forest Science Journal, 2012
- Survival of southern pine seedlings after inoculations with Pythium and cold storage in the presence of peat mossForest Pathology, 2011
- Growth response analysis after early control of woody competition for 14 loblolly pine plantations in the southern U.S.Forest Ecology and Management, 2007
- Statistical power in forest monitoringForest Ecology and Management, 2001
- Response of direct seeded Pinus Palustris and herbaceous vegetation to fertilization, burning, and pine straw harvestingBiomass and Bioenergy, 1998
- Sample-size needs for forestry herbicide trialsCanadian Journal of Forest Research, 1993
- On the presentation of statistical analysis: reason or ritualCanadian Journal of Forest Research, 1986
- Chemical root pruning of Chinese pine seedlings raised in cupric sulfide impregnated paper containersNew Forests, 1986
- Comparing treatment means correctly and appropriatelyCanadian Journal of Forest Research, 1985