Abstract
Two methodological approaches are commonly used to investigate heterotrophic nitrification (Nit h ) in soil: process inhibitions and 15 N tracing. Although many studies have reported Nit h based on 15 N tracing approaches, estimates via specific inhibitor are less common. Therefore, we conducted a meta‐analysis to illustrate the similarities and differences of the results of soil Nit h between the two approaches. We observed that the average result of gross Nit h rate was significantly lower with the 15 N tracing approach (1.32 mg N kg −1 day −1 ) than with the inhibitor approach (3.54 mg N kg −1 day −1 ) ( p < 0.01). Possible explanations include incomplete inhibition of autotrophic nitrification (Nit a ) due to the adsorption of inhibitors on soil aggregates and the fact that the estimation of Nit h via 15 N tracing quantifies only the Nit h fraction related to organic N oxidation. The results of linear‐mixed models indicated that soil C:N ratio had a significantly positive effect on the difference of Nit h estimated via 15 N tracing and inhibitor approach, which was also supported by the paired data between natural and C‐ and N‐ manipulated soil. The average contribution of Nit h to total nitrification, estimated by the ratio of Nit h :(Nit h + Nit a ) or the capacity of NO 2 − /NO 3 − production when Nit a was inhibited, in the two approaches were not significantly different (34% vs. 33%). While, soil C:N ratio also caused a significantly positive effect on the contribution of Nit h to soil total nitrification ( p < 0.05). In conclusion, the result of the relative contribution of Nit h is less affected by approach than the result of gross Nit h rate. In addition, soil C and N substrate availability is likely to be a critical factor affecting the estimation of soil Nit h by the two approaches. Highlights: Process inhibitors and 15 N tracing are two commonly used methods to quantify soil heterotrophic nitrification (Nit h ). A meta‐analysis was carried out to compare the results of soil Nit h between the two methods. There was a significant difference of the rate of Nit h estimated via the two methods, while the contribution of Nit h to total nitrification was similar. Soil C and N substrate appeared to influence the estimation of soil Nit h via the two approaches.
Funding Information
  • International Atomic Energy Agency
  • National Natural Science Foundation of China (41830642, 42103076)

This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit: