Alar Battens Grafts Versus Lateral Crural Strut Grafts: A Systematic Review of Postoperative Outcomes
Open Access
- 8 September 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery
- Vol. 173 (6) , 1328-1336
Abstract
Objective: To systematically compare functional outcomes and postoperative cosmetic satisfaction following alar batten graft (ABG) versus lateral crural strut graft (LCSG) placement for patients with nasal valve incompetence. Data Sources: Pubmed and Embase searches (1995‐2025) with terms for nasal obstruction, LCSG, ABG, and functional/cosmetic outcomes. Review Methods: Relevant studies with documented preoperative nasal valve incompetence, confirmed surgical intervention with either ABG or LCSG, and their associated postoperative outcomes were identified. Review methods adhered to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta‐analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Due to heterogeneous study designs and incomplete variance data, the findings are presented as ranges without a quantitative meta‐analysis. Results: Fifteen studies (n = 1052 patients; LCSG = 690, ABG = 362) were included. Among eight LCSG studies, mean nasal obstruction symptom evaluation (NOSE) score improvements ranged from 15.8 to 65.6 points, and visual analog scale (VAS)‐function improvements ranged from 10.1 to 44.3 points. Seven ABG studies demonstrated NOSE improvements of 25.6 to 69.0 points, and VAS‐function improvements ranged from 24.0 to 54.5 points. Validated cosmetic patient‐reported outcome measures (Standardized Cosmesis and Health Nasal Outcomes Survey [SCHNOS]‐C, VAS‐cosmesis, and Facial Aesthetic Clinical Evaluation‐Questionnaire [FACE‐Q]) were used in LCSG cohorts, showing consistent esthetic gains. No ABG studies employed a standardized cosmetic measure. Heterogeneity precluded pooled analysis. Conclusion: Both ABG and LCSG yield substantial functional improvements for nasal valve incompetence across numerous studies. Cosmetic satisfaction appears favorable for LCSG but is undercharacterized for ABG due to a lack of reported standardized patient outcome measures. Large, prospective, and multi‐institutional studies investigating outcome differences are needed, given the significant heterogeneity across study methods in the existing literature.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Effect of Functional Rhinoplasty on Quality of Life: A Systematic Review and Meta-AnalysisAesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2023
- Effect of Lateral Crural Procedures on Nasal Wall Stability and Tip Aesthetics in RhinoplastyThe Laryngoscope, 2021
- The internal nasal valve: a validated grading system and operative guideEuropean Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology, 2018
- The 10-Item Standardized Cosmesis and Health Nasal Outcomes Survey (SCHNOS) for Functional and Cosmetic RhinoplastyJAMA Facial Plastic Surgery, 2018
- Costal Cartilage Lateral Crural Strut Graft vs Cephalic Crural Turn-in for Correction of External Valve DysfunctionJAMA Facial Plastic Surgery, 2015
- Aesthetic and Functional Results of Lateral Crural RepositioningJAMA Facial Plastic Surgery, 2015
- The Effects of Alar Batten Grafts on Nasal Airway Obstruction and Nasal Steroid Use in Patients With Nasal Valve Collapse and Nasal Allergic SymptomsJAMA Facial Plastic Surgery, 2013
- Effects of various submucous resection techniques of septal cartilage on nasal tip projectionInternational Forum of Allergy & Rhinology, 2011
- Alar Batten Cartilage Graft: Treatment of Internal and External Nasal Valve CollapseAesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2009
- Use of Alar Batten Grafts for Correction of Nasal Valve CollapseJAMA Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery, 1997