Actuality Entailments: When the Modality is in the Presupposition
Author:
Open Access
- 10 November 2016
- book chapter
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 191-210
Abstract
In natural language, modals are not implicative. However, when the modality is combined with the perfective, it shows an implicative (or factive) behavior. This phenomenon is called ‘actuality entailment’. We show that actuality entailments arise with goal-oriented modality only and endorse Belnap’s view of that goal-oriented modals use historical accessibility with a fixed past and an open future. This modal-theoretic assumption allows us to spell out the precise modal-temporal configuration in which the actuality entailment arises and our predictions are borne out by the data, cross-linguistically. We also show that, when any assumption about the identity of worlds at branching point is leveled - which appears to be the case with generic deontic and opportunity modals, the actuality entailments disappear. We also predict that the entailment disappears with prospectivity. Finally, we argue that modal sentences giving rise to actuality entailments are informative, insofar as the contribution of the modality survives as a presupposition that the modal base is non-homogeneous.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Each Other, Asymmetry and Reasonable FuturesJournal of Semantics, 2013
- Toward a Taxonomy of Projective ContentLanguage, 2013
- Ability, Action, and Causation: From Pure Ability to Force∗2012
- Introduction2012
- Must . . . stay . . . strong!Natural Language Semantics, 2010
- Local ContextsSemantics and Pragmatics, 2009
- On the interaction of aspect and modal auxiliariesLinguistics and Philosophy, 2009
- Future and non-future modal sentencesNatural Language Semantics, 2006
- Sur l'imparfait contrefactuelTravaux de linguistique, 2006
- Backwards and Forwards in the Modal Logic of AgencyPhilosophy and Phenomenological Research, 1991