The Limits of Procedural Discretion
Open Access
- 28 July 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social & Legal Studies
- Vol. 27 (1) , 49-78
Abstract
Studies of procedural in-court judicial discretion have highlighted a dilemma between the imperative to reduce it owing to its potential misuse and preserve it owing to its importance in protecting vulnerable groups. This article offers a new framework with which to enter this debate and new quantitative empirical evidence that favours the former position over the latter. Drawing upon 240 in-person observations of Britain’s First Tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber), the article demonstrates that judicial discretionary behaviour that is either vulnerability-neutral, vulnerability-amplifying or correlated with extraneous factors outweighs vulnerability-redressing behaviour, despite the sensitivity of this particular jurisdiction and the guidelines that consequently exist for judges. These findings lend support to calls to limit judicial procedural discretion. The article concludes by offering some cost-effective suggestions about how to do so.Keywords
Funding Information
- Economic and Social Research Council (ES/J023426/1)
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- ‘Hearing the Right Gaps’Social & Legal Studies, 2012
- Extraneous factors in judicial decisionsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2011
- On Silence, Sexuality and Skeletons: Reconceptualizing Narrative in Asylum HearingsSocial & Legal Studies, 2011
- Judges and Their WorkSocial & Legal Studies, 2011
- Sentencing as Craftwork and the Binary Epistemologies of the Discretionary Decision ProcessSocial & Legal Studies, 2007
- The Passive Arbiter: Litigants in Person and the Challenge To NeutralitySocial & Legal Studies, 2007
- `Getting Through the List': Judgecraft and Legitimacy in the Lower CourtsSocial & Legal Studies, 2007
- Toward a Theorization of CraftSocial & Legal Studies, 2007
- Judgecraft: an IntroductionSocial & Legal Studies, 2007
- The "process" of field research in the courtroom: A descriptive analysis.Law and Human Behavior, 1987