(Ir) Reconcilable Differences? The Debate Concerning Nursing and Technology
- 1 June 1997
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Image: the Journal of Nursing Scholarship
- Vol. 29 (2) , 169-174
Abstract
Purpose: To review and critique the debate concerning nursing and technology. Technology has been considered both at one at odds with nursing.Organizing Construct: Mitcham's (1994) concepts of technological optimism and romanticism.Source: Nursing literature since 1960.Methods: Historical analysis.Findings: Technological optimists in nursing have viewed technology as an extension of and as readily assimilable into humanistic nursing practice, and nursing as socially advantaged by technology. Technological romantics have viewed technology as irreconcilable with nursing culture, as an expression of masculine culture, and as recirculating existing gender and social inequalities.Conclusions: Both optimists and romantics essentialize technology and nursing, treating the two as singular and fixed entities. The (ir)reconcilability of nursing and technology may be a function of how devices are used by people in different contexts, or of the (ir)reconcilability of views of technology in nursing.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Machine Technologies and Caring in NursingImage: the Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 1995
- The professionalization of anesthesiology—AgainSocial Science & Medicine, 1984
- Preserving the essence of nursing in a technological age*Journal of Advanced Nursing, 1980
- Nurses Undertake Direct and Indirect Fetal Monitoring at a Community HospitalJOGN Nursing, 1974
- THIS I BELIEVE … THAT NURSES MAY BECOME EXTINCTAORN Journal, 1970
- Information technologies and health care. 2. The need for new technologies to offset the shortage of physiciansArchives of internal medicine (1960), 1970
- HEMODIALYSIS FOR ACUTE RENAL FAILUREAJN, American Journal of Nursing, 1965
- NURSING IN A CORONARY CARE UNITAJN, American Journal of Nursing, 1965
- ELECTRONIC MONITORING OF VITAL SIGNSAJN, American Journal of Nursing, 1965
- Editorial: Mastering the MysteriesAJN, American Journal of Nursing, 1965