Information distortion as a source of overconfidence in managerial decisions
Authors:
Open Access
- 9 February 2026
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Judgment and Decision Making
- Vol. 21
Abstract
Managers confronting important strategic decisions often receive diagnostic information sequentially over time. As new information becomes available, they may need to update their understanding of the situation and possibly revise their preferences. During a decision, as a preference develops for one alternative course of action, a nonconscious goal of maintaining consistency between that preference, however tentative, and the new information can lead to an interpretation of that information so as to support the current preference. This tendency to bias or distort information to support the currently preferred option can in turn lead to even greater confidence in that leading option, despite the increase in confidence being unwarranted by the information itself. The result of such a biased decision process can be overconfidence in the chosen course of action. To show this, in the current work, experienced managers engaged in a realistic business decision task with their levels of information distortion and confidence tracked throughout the decision. Over the course of the decision, confidence in the leading action increased as a function of distortion. The results confirmed that distortion-driven confidence can develop even when decision makers have no prior preference for one of the outcomes.Keywords
This publication has 73 references indexed in Scilit:
- Benefiting From Disagreement: Counterarguing Reduces Prechoice Bias in Information EvaluationJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2017
- Are We All Overconfident in the Long Run? Evidence from One Million Marathon ParticipantsJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2016
- Overprecision in Judgment2015
- A Goal‐Priming Approach to Cognitive Consistency: Applications to JudgmentJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2015
- Making sense of overconfidence in market entryStrategic Management Journal, 2013
- Identifying the Effects of Unjustified Confidence versus Overconfidence: Lessons Learned from Two Analytic MethodsJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2013
- Leader‐driven distortion of probability and payoff information affects choices between risky prospectsJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2011
- The Value of Task Conflict to Group DecisionsJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2011
- Coherence shifts in probabilistic inference tasksJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2010
- Must boxing verdicts be biased?Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 1991