Physicians' Attitudes Towards the Advice of a Guideline-Based Decision Support System: A Case Study With OncoDoc2 in the Management of Breast Cancer Patients
Authors:
- Bouaud JacquesBJBouaud Jacques
- Spano Jean-PhilippeSJSpano Jean-Philippe
- Lefranc Jean-PierreLJLefranc Jean-Pierre
- Cojean-Zelek IsabelleCICojean-Zelek Isabelle
- Blaszka-Jaulerry BrigitteBBBlaszka-Jaulerry Brigitte
- Zelek LaurentZLZelek Laurent
- Durieux AxelDADurieux Axel
- Tournigand ChristopheTCTournigand Christophe
- Rousseau AlexandraRARousseau Alexandra
- Vandenbussche Pierre-YvesVPVandenbussche Pierre-Yves
- SÉRoussi BrigitteSBSÉRoussi Brigitte
Open Access
- 1 January 2015
- book chapter
- Published by IOS Press
- p. 264-269
Abstract
When wrongly used, guideline-based clinical decision support systems (CDSSs) may generate inappropriate propositions that do not match the recommendations provided by clinical practice guidelines (CPGs). The user may decide to comply with or react to the CDSS, and her decision may finally comply or not with CPGs. OncoDoc2 is a guideline-based CDSS for breast cancer management. We collected 394 decisions made by multidisciplinary meeting physicians in three hospitals where the CDSS was evaluated. We observed a global CPG compliance of 86.8% and a global CDSS compliance of 75.4%. Non-CPG compliance was observed in case of a negative reactance to the CDSS, when users did not follow a correct CDSS proposition (8.6% of decisions). Because of errors in patient data entry, OncoDoc2 delivered non-recommended propositions in 21.3% of decisions, leading to compliances with CDSS and CPGs of respectively 21.4% and 65.5%, whereas both compliances exceeded 90% when CDSS advices included CPG recommendations. Automation bias, when users followed an incorrect CDSS proposition explained the remaining non-compliance with CPGs (4.6% of decisions). Securing the use of CDSSs is of major importance to warranty patient safety and benefit of their potential to improve care.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Quality improvement by implementing an integrated oncological care pathway for breast cancer patientsThe Breast, 2014
- Automation bias: Empirical results assessing influencing factorsInternational Journal of Medical Informatics, 2014
- Forty years of unwarranted variation—And still countingHealth Policy, 2014
- Which breast cancer decisions remain non-compliant with guidelines despite the use of computerised decision support?British Journal of Cancer, 2013
- A comparative review of patient safety initiatives for national health information technologyInternational Journal of Medical Informatics, 2013
- Features of effective computerised clinical decision support systems: meta-regression of 162 randomised trialsBMJ, 2013
- Tumor Boards and the Quality of Cancer CareJNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 2012
- Effects of guideline adherence in primary breast cancer–A 5-year multi-center cohort study of 3976 patientsThe Breast, 2010
- Defining and measuring physicians’ responses to clinical remindersJournal of Biomedical Informatics, 2009
- OncoDoc: a successful experiment of computer-supported guideline development and implementation in the treatment of breast cancerArtificial Intelligence in Medicine, 2001