Rubric-based holistic review: A promising route to equitable graduate admissions in physics
Open Access
- 30 November 2022
- journal article
- review article
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Physics Education Research
- Vol. 18 (2) , 020140
Abstract
As systematic inequities in higher education and society have been brought to the forefront, graduate programs are interested in increasing the diversity of their applicants and enrollees. Yet, structures in place to evaluate applicants may not support such aims. One potential solution to support those aims is rubric-based holistic review. Starting in 2018, our physics department implemented a rubric-based holistic review process for all applicants to our graduate program. The rubric assessed applicants on 18 metrics covering their grades, test scores, research experiences, noncognitive competencies, and fit with the program. We then compared faculty’s ratings of applicants by admission status, sex, and undergraduate program over a three-year period. We find that the rubric scores show statistically significant differences between admitted and nonadmitted students as hoped. We also find that differences in rubric scores based on sex or undergraduate program reflected known systematic inequities such as applicants from smaller and less prestigious undergraduate universities scoring lower on the physics GRE and women performing more volunteer work in academia. Our results then suggest rubric-based holistic review as a possible route to making graduate admissions in physics more equitable.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- College of Natural Science, Michigan State University
- Lappan-Phillips Foundation
This publication has 72 references indexed in Scilit:
- Toward Inclusive Excellence in Graduate Education: Constructing Merit and Diversity in PhD AdmissionsAmerican Journal of Education, 2014
- Employing Noncognitive Variables to Improve Admissions, and Increase Student Diversity and RetentionStrategic Enrollment Management Quarterly, 2013
- Science faculty’s subtle gender biases favor male studentsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2012
- The Fisk-Vanderbilt Master’s-to-Ph.D. Bridge Program: Recognizing, enlisting, and cultivating unrealized or unrecognized potential in underrepresented minority studentsAmerican Journal of Physics, 2011
- Back to the future: Personality and Assessment and personality developmentJournal of Research in Personality, 2009
- THE DIVERSITY–VALIDITY DILEMMA: STRATEGIES FOR REDUCING RACIOETHNIC AND SEX SUBGROUP DIFFERENCES AND ADVERSE IMPACT IN SELECTIONPersonnel Psychology, 2008
- Big Five personality predictors of post-secondary academic performancePersonality and Individual Differences, 2007
- Effectiveness of medical school admissions criteria in predicting residency ranking four years laterMedical Education, 2006
- Noncognitive Constructs and Their Assessment in Graduate Education: A ReviewEducational Assessment, 2005
- The Reliability of Non-Cognitive Admissions Measures in Predicting Non-traditional Doctor of Pharmacy Student Performance OutcomesAmerican Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, 2003