Force comparison between Perfitalign 4D aligners and thermoformed aligners for mandibular incisor retraction: an in vitro study
Authors:
Open Access
- 30 October 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Progress in Orthodontics
- Vol. 26 (1) , 1-17
Abstract
To quantitatively compare the orthodontic forces exerted during mandibular incisor retraction by Perfitalign 4D aligners and thermoformed aligners over a 60-hour dynamic monitoring period, assess tooth movement trends, and investigate the effects of shape-memory properties on force characteristics. Three groups of aligners were designed for mandibular incisor retraction. Group A aligners were fabricated using Erkodur foils (ERKODENT Erich Kopp) via thermoforming, while Groups B and C were fabricated using DCA resin (LuxCreo) via 3D printing. Groups A and B possessed a step size of 0.15 mm, whereas group C had a step size of 0.20 mm. Force data were monitored on a mandibular model for 60 h using a multi-axis transducer at 4-hour wear intervals. Groups B and C underwent thermal reactivation after every 12 h of cumulative wear, with recordings taken immediately before and after each activation. All groups exhibited high repeatability (ICC > 0.9). Perfitalign 4D aligners exhibited significant force recovery after thermal reactivation, though the recovery degree slightly decreased with repeated activations. Vertical forces markedly fluctuated but increased after thermal reactivation. Intergroup comparisons revealed significantly lower lingual forces in groups B/C compared to group A (P < 0.05). For mesiodistal and vertical directions, forces in groups B/C showed no significant reductions compared to group A. Residual stress analysis revealed rapid initial decay in group A, which decelerated subsequently, while groups B and C exhibited cyclic characteristics of “decay—thermal reactivation-induced recovery—decay”. At 0 h, moment-to-force ratios (Mx/Fy) for mandibular incisors were significantly lower in groups B/C (− 3.3 to − 8.7 mm) than in group A (− 8.0 to − 10.7 mm). Perfitalign 4D aligners enable cyclic force recovery via shape-memory properties, independent of step size (0.15/0.20 mm). Despite larger steps, their lingual forces remained significantly lower than those of thermoformed aligners. A trend closer to bodily movement was observed with Perfitalign 4D aligners, although clinical studies are needed to validate movement efficiency and the long-term effects of elevated mesiodistal/vertical forces.Keywords
Funding Information
- the National Clinical Research Center for Oral Diseases (LCA202202, LCB202202)
- Key Project of the Shaanxi Provincial Key Research and Development Program (2024SF-GJHX-37)
- New Technologies and New Business of School of Stomatology, Air Force Medical University Fund (LX-2023-102,LX2022-306,LX2021-204)
- The National Natural Science Foundation of China (8240036014)
This publication has 70 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effect of applying intermittent force with and without vibration on orthodontic tooth movementJournal of Orofacial Orthopedics / Fortschritte der Kieferorthopädie, 2023
- Investigating the role of aligner material and tooth position on orthodontic aligner biomechanicsJournal of Biomedical Materials Research Part B: Applied Biomaterials, 2022
- Variation of the modulus of elasticity of aligner foil sheet materials due to thermoformingJournal of Orofacial Orthopedics / Fortschritte der Kieferorthopädie, 2021
- Biomechanical analysis of initial incisor crowding alignment in the periodontally reduced mandible using the finite element methodJournal of Orofacial Orthopedics / Fortschritte der Kieferorthopädie, 2019
- Forces and moments delivered by PET-G aligners to an upper central incisor for labial and palatal translationJournal of Orofacial Orthopedics / Fortschritte der Kieferorthopädie, 2015
- Numerical simulation and biomechanical analysis of an orthodontically treated periodontally damaged dentitionJournal of Orofacial Orthopedics / Fortschritte der Kieferorthopädie, 2013
- Physical properties of root cementum: Part 23. Effects of 2 or 3 weekly reactivated continuous or intermittent orthodontic forces on root resorption and tooth movement: A microcomputed tomography studyAmerican Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2012
- Physical properties of root cementum: Part 11. Continuous vs intermittent controlled orthodontic forces on root resorption. A microcomputed-tomography studyAmerican Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2009
- Effect of 8-hour intermittent orthodontic force on osteoclasts and root resorptionAmerican Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2009
- Cellular, molecular, and tissue-level reactions to orthodontic forceAmerican Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2006