Differentiated Decoupling and Human Rights
- 19 September 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Social Problems
- Vol. 63 (4) , 499-512
Abstract
One of the major issues attracting the attention of scholars studying global norm regimes, especially the human rights regime, is their impact on domestic settings. Borrowing from organizational studies, some of these scholars have used the term decoupling to conceptualize the widespread phenomenon of states that sign conventions but do not implement these conventions’ norms. In this article, we introduce the concept of differentiated decoupling, arguing that the implementation of human rights norms needs to be rethought and reoperationalized. We present a case study—the right to vote in the United States—to illustrate our argument that it is vital to disaggregate the decoupling processes and examine the different social groups within the state rather than limit scrutiny to the state level. We further contend that in order to explain differentiated decoupling, perspectives developed and used by sociologists who study inequality need to be adopted. In this way, scholars can capture the unequal distribution of human rights in domestic settings and begin to untangle the forces leading to differentiated decoupling. An analysis of differentiated decoupling helps reveal that “more human rights” sometimes means more human rights to one group and less to another, suggesting that implementation of human rights norms may even deepen stratification. Uno de los principales problemas que atraen la atención de investigadores que estudian las normas de los regímenes globales, especialmente el régimen de derechos humanos, es su impacto en el entorno doméstico. Utilizando theorias de estudios organizacionales, algunos de estos investigadores han utilizado el término disociación para conceptualizar el fenómeno generalizado de los estados que firman convenciones pero que no implementan estas normas. En este trabajo, se introduce el concepto de desacoplamiento diferenciado, argumentando que la aplicación de las normas de derechos humanos necesitan ser re-pensadas y re-operacionalizadas. Se presenta un estudio del caso - el derecho al voto en los EE.UU. - para ilustrar nuestro argumento que es vital para desagregar los procesos de desacoplamiento y examinar los diferentes grupos sociales dentro del estado en lugar de limitar el escrutinio a nivel estatal. Sostenemos, además, que con el fin de explicar la disociación diferenciada, perspectivas desarrolladas y utilizadas por los sociólogos que estudian la desigualdad necesitan ser adoptadas. De esta manera, los investigadores pueden capturar la distribución desigual de los derechos humanos en el ámbito doméstico y comenzar a esclarecer las fuerzas que conducen a la disociación diferenciada. Un análisis de desacoplamiento diferencial ayuda a revelar que "más derechos humanos" significan más derechos humanos a un grupo y menos a otro, lo que sugiere que la aplicación de las normas de derechos humanos incluso pueden profundizar la estratificación.Keywords
This publication has 76 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Use and Misuse of the “Minorities at Risk” ProjectAnnual Review of Political Science, 2013
- Predicting Recidivism for Released State Prison OffendersCriminal Justice and Behavior, 2013
- From Smoke and Mirrors to Walking the Talk: Decoupling in the Contemporary WorldAcademy of Management Annals, 2012
- World Society, Social Differentiation and TimeInternational Political Sociology, 2012
- Institutional Complexity and Organizational ResponsesAcademy of Management Annals, 2011
- Estimating the Effects of Human Rights Treaties on State BehaviorThe Journal of Politics, 2010
- Incarceration and StratificationAnnual Review of Sociology, 2010
- The Black Family and Mass IncarcerationThe Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 2009
- Corporate social and environmental responsibility in Asian countries and other geographical regionsCorporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 2007
- Racial Profiling and Immigration Law Enforcement: Rounding Up of Usual Suspects in the Latino CommunityCritical Sociology, 2006