The Bread-Making Machine: Tacit Knowledge and Two Types of Action
Authors:
- 1 September 2007
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Organization Studies
- Vol. 28 (9) , 1417-1433
Abstract
We analyse Nonaka and Takeuchi's (1995) claim that a master baker's tacit knowledge was made explicit and incorporated into a home bread-making machine and its manual — the `knowledge capture' thesis. In order to test the claim, bread was made without and with a breadmaker and we carried out an analysis of the bread-making actions before and after mechanization. Based on the theory of action morphicity (Collins and Kusch 1998) it is shown that the machine only mimics the mechanical counterpart of just a few of certain special kinds of human bread-making actions. The remaining success of the machine and its manual is due to what other human actors bring to the mechanical bread-making scene; this way the breadmaker can be an adequate social prosthesis. Action mimicking, action substitution, and the contributions of these other human actors, who are not needed in the case of the master baker, explain why the machine and its manual do work. It is not a matter of the explication or incorporation of tacit knowledge, but of fitting a social prosthesis into a rearranged world.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Bicycling on the Moon: Collective Tacit Knowledge and Somatic-limit Tacit KnowledgeOrganization Studies, 2007
- How Does Tacit Knowledge Proliferate? An Episode-Based PerspectiveOrganization Studies, 2006
- The Knowledge-Creating Company1995
- Stories, Tacit Knowledge, and Psychotherapy ResearchPsychotherapy Research, 1995
- Simon's SlezakSocial Studies of Science, 1991
- Comments on the Symposium on `Computer Discovery and the Sociology of Scientific Knowledge'Social Studies of Science, 1991
- Artificial Experts1990
- Configuring the User: The Case of Usability TrialsThe Sociological Review, 1990
- Computers and the Sociology of Scientific Knowledge1Social Studies of Science, 1989
- The TEA Set: Tacit Knowledge and Scientific NetworksScience Studies, 1974