Philosophical perspectives on response shift
- 28 October 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Quality of Life Research
- Vol. 22 (7) , 1871-1878
Abstract
Purpose This paper brings a philosophical perspective to response shift research with the aim of raising new critical questions, clarifying some of the concepts employed, and providing a philosophical context within which to critically examine the assumptions that shape the field. Methods This critical analysis aims to reveal assumptions and clarify concepts and/or definitions that undergird methodological practice and theory. Results We bring attention to the distinction of weak and strong evaluations, and the implications and consequences for construct validity and for designing patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs). We then consider the epistemology of PROMs, suggesting that they are better suited to a social constructivist approach than a scientific realist one. Finally, we examine the relationship between disability and response shift, arguing that in at least some cases, response shifts should not be understood as ‘measurement bias’. Conclusion Our analysis reveals various concerns and further questions related to the role that substantive values play in the assessment of QoL. It also draws response shift into a wider arena, with broader issues of interpretation, self-evaluation, the meaning of the ‘good life’, and the status and legitimacy we accord to various scientific methods.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- What is human agency?2012
- Interpretability, validity, and the minimum important differenceTheoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 2011
- A theoretical framework for patient-reported outcome measuresTheoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 2010
- Listen to their answers! Response behaviour in the measurement of physical and role functioningQuality of Life Research, 2008
- Response Shift Theory: Important Implications for Measuring Quality of Life in People With DisabilityArchives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 2007
- Small-cell lung cancer patients are just ‘a little bit’ tired: response shift and self-presentation in the measurement of fatigueQuality of Life Research, 2007
- Evolutionary ethics: can values changeJournal of Medical Ethics, 2004
- Listening to respondents:Social Science & Medicine, 2002
- Methodological approaches for assessing response shift in longitudinal health-related quality-of-life researchSocial Science & Medicine, 1999
- WEIGHTING HEALTH STATES AND STRONG EVALUATION*Bioethics, 1995