The Never-Ending Crisis of Italian Justice: Role and Responsibility of its Governance System
Open Access
- 30 May 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Queensland University of Technology in Law, Technology and Humans
- Vol. 5 (1) , 153-177
Abstract
This article analyses four critical dimensions of the Italian justice system’s enduring condition critical: poor predictability of judicial decisions, lack of integrity, low trust, and excessive length of judicial procedures. While the first three critical areas have multiple causes, the role of the dual judicial governance structure, with competencies split between the Ministry of Justice and the Judicial Council, is identified as a relevant cause of lengthy procedures. Judicial statistics show how procedural delays are caused by the inefficient use of available resources due to obsolete allocation mechanisms and high variations in courts’ efficiency. This article argues that cutting-edge resource-allocation systems and integrated court management mechanisms based on workload or performance indicators demand a sustained and coordinated effort between the Ministry and the Council, which may be hard to achieve. More generally, the different constituencies and the competence split between the two bodies make the implementation of integrated judicial management approaches unlikely. The explanation is based on structural and institutional features common to all systems in which two bodies share responsibility on the same policy and managerial areas, so findings are potentially relevant to all judiciaries with this feature. The analysis also gives a reason for the negative correlation between judicial governance settings based on the French or Italian model and judicial efficiency.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Judicial Self‐Governance Index: Towards better understanding of the role of judges in governing the judiciaryRegulation & Governance, 2022
- A performance-based budget in the judiciary: allocation of resources and performance variability in first instance courts. An analysis of three case studiesJournal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 2020
- Judicial Self-Governance in the New Millennium2020
- The politics of implementation of the judicial council model in EuropeEuropean Political Science Review, 2019
- Beyond Judicial Councils: Forms, Rationales and Impact of Judicial Self-Governance in EuropeGerman Law Journal, 2018
- Identifying the determinants of aggregate judicial performance: taxpayers’ money well spent?European Journal of Law and Economics, 2014
- Organization Development of the Dutch Judiciary, between Accountability and Judicial IndependenceInternational Journal for Court Administration, 2010
- Justice systems and ICT What can be learned from Europe?Utrecht Law Review, 2007
- Judicial accountability in the US State Courts Measuring court performanceUtrecht Law Review, 2007
- Social and Political Aspects of Civil Procedure: Reforms and Trends in Western and Eastern EuropeMichigan Law Review, 1971