Comparison of Review Articles Published in Peer-Reviewed and Throwaway Journals
Authors:
- Paula A. RochonPRPaula A. Rochon
- Lisa A. BeroLBLisa A. Bero
- Ari M. BayABAri M. Bay
- Jennifer L. GoldJGJennifer L. Gold
- Julie M. DergalJDJulie M. Dergal
- Malcolm A. BinnsMBMalcolm A. Binns
- David L. StreinerDSDavid L. Streiner
- Jerry H. GurwitzJGJerry H. Gurwitz
Open Access
- 5 June 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in JAMA
- Vol. 287 (21) , 2853-2856
Abstract
ContextTo compare the quality, presentation, readability, and clinical relevance of review articles published in peer-reviewed and "throwaway" journals.MethodsWe reviewed articles that focused on the diagnosis or treatment of a medical condition published between January 1 and December 31, 1998, in the 5 leading peer-reviewed general medical journals and high-circulation throwaway journals. Reviewers independently assessed the methodologic and reporting quality, and evaluated each article's presentation and readability. Clinical relevance was evaluated independently by 6 physicians.ResultsOf the 394 articles in our sample, 16 (4.1%) were peer-reviewed systematic reviews, 135 (34.3%) were peer-reviewed nonsystematic reviews, and 243 (61.7%) were nonsystematic reviews published in throwaway journals. The mean (SD) quality scores were highest for peer-reviewed articles (0.94 [0.09] for systematic reviews and 0.30 [0.19] for nonsystematic reviews) compared with throwaway journal articles (0.23 [0.03], F2,391 = 280.8, P<.001). Throwaway journal articles used more tables (P = .02), figures (P = .01), photographs (P<.001), color (P<.001), and larger font sizes (P<.001) compared with peer-reviewed articles. Readability scores were more often in the college or higher range for peer-reviewed journals compared with the throwaway journal articles (104 [77.0%] vs 156 [64.2%]; P = .01). Peer-reviewed article titles were judged less relevant to clinical practice than throwaway journal article titles (P<.001).ConclusionsAlthough lower in methodologic and reporting quality, review articles published in throwaway journals have characteristics that appeal to physician readers.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Why Review Articles on the Health Effects of Passive Smoking Reach Different ConclusionsJAMA, 1998
- Locating and Appraising Systematic ReviewsAnnals of Internal Medicine, 1997
- Scientific quality of original research articles on environmental tobacco smokeTobacco Control, 1997
- How to keep up with the critical care literature and avoid being buried aliveCritical Care Medicine, 1996
- Too Many Words? Mozart 1, Emperor 01995
- Agreement among reviewers of review articlesJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1991
- Validation of an index of the quality of review articlesJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1991
- Throw it away, Sam: the controlled circulation journals.American Journal of Roentgenology, 1990
- The Medical Review Article: State of the ScienceAnnals of Internal Medicine, 1987
- A new readability yardstick.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1948