On the compatibility of carbon uptake rates calculated from stable and radioactive isotope data: implications for the design of experimental protocols in aquatic primary productivity
Basic differences between the 13C and the 14C techniques of measuring carbon uptake by phytoplankton exist at the level of the isotopic analysis. With the first method, a ratio of isotopic abundances is measured on the sample, whereas an absolute amount of isotope is estimated with the second method. If a carbon source other than the labeled one is utilized by the phytoplankton during incubation, the stable isotope method may be biased. Specific uptake values will be underestimated by this effect. It is, however, possible to obtain unbiased estimates of the 13C-labeled carbon uptake by using an equation containing a term describing the final particulate carbon concentration. Only under this condition will carbon uptake rates derived from 13C isotope data be always compatible with the 13C method of measuring primary production