What Could Go Wrong? Promoting Success by Planning for Failure in Label-Free Biosensor Assay Development
Authors:
- Sajida ChowdhurySCSajida Chowdhury
- Samantha M. GristSGSamantha M. Grist
- Avineet RandhawaARAvineet Randhawa
- Maggie WangMWMaggie Wang
- Karyn NewtonKNKaryn Newton
- Lauren S. PuumalaLPLauren S. Puumala
- Yuting HouYHYuting Hou
- Lukas ChrostowskiLCLukas Chrostowski
- Sudip ShekharSSSudip Shekhar
- Karen C. CheungKCKaren C. Cheung
Preprint
Abstract
Label-free biosensors offer powerful platforms for detecting molecular interactions, but developing robust assays on these systems presents several challenges due to the complexity of the testing systems and intersection of disciplines. In this work, we describe a lightweight, 3-step experimental workflow supporting troubleshooting and root cause analysis that we developed during the design and optimization of silicon photonic biosensor assays in an academic research setting. Because such environments often lack the resources and formal quality-management infrastructure available in industry, our approach emphasizes practicality and ease of adoption. Drawing from our own assay failures and successes, we identify common failure modes, propose structured troubleshooting workflows, and provide case studies illustrating the application of established frameworks, including the Five Whys, the Plan-Do-Check-Act cycle, Open-Narrow-Close and the Ishikawa (fishbone) diagram. By applying this framework to our research, we increased our assay yield by a factor of 2, from ~45% to ~90%. This paper aims to support other teams engaged in label-free assay development by equipping them with practical tools and experimental best practices. Highlights: We doubled assay yield from ~45% to ~90% by planning for failure, not just success. Tailored troubleshooting frameworks help pinpoint and solve various assay failures. Applying innovative problem-solving to workflows accelerates biosensor development. Systematic troubleshooting improves assay development across a range of lab settings. A 3-step workflow highlighting what could go wrong supports continuous improvement.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Biosensors and Bioelectronics: X, 29.
Funding Information
- Schmidt Science Polymaths Program
- Optica Foundation Challenge
- School of Biomedical Engineering Trainee Research Awards Program
- MITACS Inc. (IT30425)
- UBC Expansion Funding for Canada’s Digital Technology Supercluster
- Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (RGPIN-2020-04798)
- Killam Trusts
- Silicon Electronics-Photonics Integrated Circuits Fabrication (SiEPICfab) Consortium
- CMC Microsystems
- Canada’s National Design Network
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Diagnosis and root cause analysis of bearing failure using vibration analysis techniquesEngineering Failure Analysis, 2024
- Bio-inspired polydopamine layer as a versatile functionalisation protocol for silicon-based photonic biosensorsTalanta, 2023
- Surface regeneration and reusability of label-free DNA biosensors based on weak polyelectrolyte-modified capacitive field-effect structuresBiosensors and Bioelectronics, 2019
- The Five Whys Technique2017
- Cytokine Levels (IL-4, IL-6, IL-8 and TGFβ) as Potential Biomarkers of Systemic Inflammatory Response in Trauma PatientsInternational Orthopaedics, 2014
- Introduction to Fault Tree Analysis (FTA)2012
- Nanostructured Immunosensor for Attomolar Detection of Cancer Biomarker Interleukin‐8 Using Massively Labeled Superparamagnetic ParticlesAngewandte Chemie International Edition, 2011
- Risk analysis by FMEA as an element of analytical validationJournal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis, 2009
- Fundamentals of Design of Experiments2003
- Experiential learning: Experience as the source of learning and development, David A. Kolb, Prentice‐Hall International, Hemel Hempstead, Herts., 1984. No. of pages: xiii + 256Journal of Organizational Behavior, 1987